Being accused of "scientific hooliganism" by a worthy adversary sounds like a new personal goal.
charliebwrites 98 days ago [-]
I wish they would’ve actually discussed _how_ the hack was accomplished
kbenson 97 days ago [-]
I think what's left unsaid and implied is that the original system wasn't secure in any way, the "tuning" was just choosing a frequency. It's only a "hack" because of the claims that were made.
In a way, that would be like advertising a secure horseback large sign delivery service, where the "security" is that the sender and receiver choose one of a few routes between locations, even though the large sign is easily seen and entirely uncovered, making the courier easily identified and the sign when in transit easily read from a distance. The "hack" for that type of system is ultimately so trivial as to be mostly uninteresting.
estimator7292 97 days ago [-]
It's just a simple AM broadcast. It was only novel at the time because radio was new.
gwbas1c 98 days ago [-]
Uhm, broadcast on the same frequency? It's not that hard to figure out what frequency Marconi was broadcasting on.
IAmBroom 97 days ago [-]
Those were the early days of radio, as in "Let there be light" kind of early.
Very few people could even build a receiver, much less tune it.
TRiG_Ireland 97 days ago [-]
Nah. He just did a broad spectrum broadcast which any receiver in the area would pick up. Today, it'd probably be illegal. Tom Scott made a video about it, and mentioned that. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sP2qqMegNKA
optimalsolver 97 days ago [-]
Title sounds like some kind of LLM prompt injection.
Rendered at 08:52:13 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.
In a way, that would be like advertising a secure horseback large sign delivery service, where the "security" is that the sender and receiver choose one of a few routes between locations, even though the large sign is easily seen and entirely uncovered, making the courier easily identified and the sign when in transit easily read from a distance. The "hack" for that type of system is ultimately so trivial as to be mostly uninteresting.
Very few people could even build a receiver, much less tune it.