NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
▲Nature-Based Sanitation. Cihuatlán: A Large-Scale Artificial Wetland (revista.unaminternacional.unam.mx)
sgirard 9 hours ago [-]
"According to the National Water Commission, only 40 percent of wastewater receives some type of treatment in Mexico. The remaining 60 percent is discharged directly into rivers and aquifers, with serious consequences for public health and ecosystems." (Edited for brevity)

I think this is a worldwide problem, but I wonder why this isn't a solved problem. Is it lack of government will? It seems like waste sanitation is a basic service any government should provide at a minimum.

toast0 7 hours ago [-]
Waste sanitation is expensive and it's kind of far down the priority list. Municipal systems typical need operators and maintenance, so it's not a one time expense.

The consequences of inadequate sanitation are somewhat subtle and diffuse. If you stop pooping in the river, that's great, but your river is still nasty if the communities upstream do it. If they clean up their outputs so it's not obviously dirty, it may still be unhealthy.

schiffern 8 hours ago [-]
I was surprised to learn that a large part of the EPA's function is just to subsidize small town sewage treatment plants, which would be hideously uneconomical otherwise.

That's another way of saying that we still haven't discovered a technology that can actually deal with our poop, but we cover up out technology failure by the simple 'hack' of throwing (civilization ruining!) quantities of money at the problem.

Engineered wetlands AKA wastewater gardens are an interesting biomimicry alternative.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6b7zJ-hx_c&t=2820s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f-sRcVkZ9yg

fc417fc802 5 hours ago [-]
> we still haven't discovered a technology that can actually deal with our poop

I think that's confusing "the US made poor regulatory choices (yet again)" with "no affordable solution exists".

schiffern 5 hours ago [-]
Preaching to the choir! Thanks, good catch.
pocksuppet 8 hours ago [-]
Just another way we are above the planet's carrying capacity
schiffern 7 hours ago [-]
We agree on the conclusion, however I don't follow that exact chain of logic.

If the sewage treatment plants can't pay for themselves, scaling up or down doesn't really help with that.[0] You're just getting more or fewer copies of the same unsustainable technology.

We are above carrying capacity, I agree. But even if we weren't, we would still need to fix our ruinously expensive sewage technology.

[0] counterpoint: if there's only one town on Earth you could just dump untreated sewage and it's no big deal, but I doubt 'human population crash' is the solution we want...

adrianN 7 hours ago [-]
You could try to internalize the costs. Perhaps we’d reduce our wastewater stream if it weren’t subsidized. There are for example composing toilets that are less convenient than normal toilets but produce no wastewater.
schiffern 7 hours ago [-]
Asking people to sacrifice always has a backlash, unfortunately. I'm not sure if we actually gain ground that way.

Real, lasting change happens when new technology pushes the cost-benefit-ratio Pareto front forward. The real game-changer IMO would be a sustainable toilet that's not (too much) less convenient or expensive.

7 hours ago [-]
fc417fc802 5 hours ago [-]
We are only above carrying capacity if you assume bizarre and arbitrary things such as subsistence agriculture. But what is the basis for that? It's like pointing out that our current economy is entirely unsustainable if you assume no access to computer chips. Yeah sure of course that's the case but what's the relevance to our modern lives?
schiffern 4 hours ago [-]
"If something cannot go on forever, it will stop." - Herbert Stein, American Enterprise Institute

Amazing how this nugget of wisdom still hasn't been internalized yet.

"Unsustainable" doesn't mean bad or evil, it just means that a system depletes or destroys the basis for its own sustenance. Unfortunately this is what human technological society does.

fc417fc802 4 hours ago [-]
This very much depends on how exactly you define the metric for carrying capacity. Synthetic fertilizer, mechanized agriculture, and renewable energy is capable of supporting a far larger population than currently exists. However, the way in which things are currently done is unsustainable. So do we qualify as being beyond carrying capacity since we could be sustainable but effectively choose not to be?
rolph 5 hours ago [-]
i cant say i have ever seen a sewage treatment plant in a sensible location. my experience, being mine is not universal, but it seems to be a universal idea to put sewage treatment on a riverside upstream from water treatment, with kudos for proximity to a popular beach. the real clincher is when a wetland is drained and filled for the sewage plant construction.
toast0 3 hours ago [-]
The problem is you have to put sewage treatment at the shore because you need to release the (hopefully) treated water, and most municipal sewers use gravity, because otherwise it gets expensive quick.

When treatment is a retrofit (which is the case for pretty much all settlements built before the 1950s), you have to put it in where it fits. Which often isn't where you'd put it if you could have planned the settlement knowing what it would need / how it would grow.

Also, it's not unusual to allocate a lot for a treatment plant and a recreation area at the same time ... have low development land use around the treatment plant can minimize the impact of overflows, leaks, storage vessel failures, etc --- you may need to close the recreation area, but there's no homes or businesses shut down.

OTOH, putting the treatment outflows upstream of freshwater intake enforces a strong commitment to meeting treatment standards?

srean 8 hours ago [-]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Calcutta_Wetlands

One of the largest waste water fed aquaculture sites in the world, could be the largest. Processes waste and keeps vegetables and fish cheap and affordable in Kolkata.

It is also a dying institution. Not sure how long it will survive.

fc417fc802 5 hours ago [-]
Bioremediation is great but I don't think it's wise to consume agricultural products raised using human sewage so directly due to various contaminants.
srean 5 hours ago [-]
Humans on a non toxic diet would be fine as long as the organic waste is properly broken down. Heavy metals are the problem.

Parasites are usually taken care of by sedimentation and appropriate fauna. Parasites that cycle through humans and the human consumables that are grown there could theoretically be a valid concern but in hundreds of years there has been no incidents.

Since there is no infrastructure to assist with safe disposal of household-items-but-not-safe-for-sewage-or-the-dumpster, people dispose fsck all in the sewage. So heavy metal contamination is now a genuine problem.

Hundred years ago the typical person did not have battery and battery acid to dispose.

pstuart 7 hours ago [-]
Seems like they should be feeding the treated water into the aquifer. It should be clean enough and the act of feeding in should ensure the water is clean.
giwook 7 hours ago [-]
I must be AI-pilled because I saw "large-scale artificial wetland" and immediately thought it was some AI-generated simulation of large-scale wetlands.
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 01:01:30 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.