NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
▲Why did modems have speakers? (2019) (retrocomputing.stackexchange.com)
II2II 5 hours ago [-]
Towards the end of the BBS era, I was trying to reach some of my old favourite haunts. Most of the calls resulted in a number not in service message coming over the speaker (which is useful in its own right), but one resulted in a perplexed and upset person picking up. I picked up the phone and explained that she ended up with the phone number of a once popular BBS. While she probably didn't like the answer, she was thankful to learn that all of those calls by screeching machines weren't from someone trying to harass her.

Those speakers were there for diagnostics of various types. One of them was figuring out when a person picked up on the other end.

rob74 3 hours ago [-]
Yeah, if you're trying to transmit data over a system originally designed for audio communication, it totally makes sense to be able to actually hear what's going on. With DSL (which works in parallel with the voice functionality without affecting it, but eventually replaced it anyway), the speaker wasn't needed anymore.
Ekaros 2 hours ago [-]
Well DSL would not have been audible anyway as it uses band which is over 30 kHz. The filters were more so to stop interference between the two bands.
kqr 6 hours ago [-]
The general name for this is mechanical sympathy. Humans have advanced sensory processing abilities, and if we design systems that use them, the performance of the humans operating the system improves. It improves for the simple reason that richer feedback leads to a better understanding of the state of the system, which in turn lets the operator predict the effects of their actions more accurately.

I think we could be a lot better at using human sound, visuals, and spatial navigation abilities in understanding software systems too, but I've never gotten around to implementing anything despite plenty of ideas.

My latest experiment is using tones and/or speech synthesis artifacts to get insight into LLM agent operation -- ongoing reasoning, tool call success/failure, etc. Still haven't really dialed it in (hah!) to be useful yet.

brainwipe 1 hours ago [-]
While mechanical sympathy is definitely a thing - modems were audio devices and so fault finding had always been audio. Everyone knew about connection clicks, what to do when there was no dial tone, hearing someone speaking meant the line was in use, the beeps you got when you connected, connection refused or connection waiting and then the hiss of data once the connection was successful. There were no other sensory signals on our phone at home. I knew one person that had a red light to show the line was in use, but that felt space age, no-one else had that and my dad worked for British Telecom!
eternauta3k 5 hours ago [-]
A bit like abacuses and bicycles, not calculators and cars.
flancian 2 hours ago [-]
Krakauer from the Santa Fe Institute calls this distinction, IIRC, complementary vs adversarial cognitive artifacts. Navigating by reading a map versus relying on GPS navigation is my other go-to example.
ssl-3 8 hours ago [-]
I used the modem speaker for all kinds of things in the BBS days. To name a few:

  - Monitoring to minimize DTMF duration (S11 register, IIRC) and maximize redialing speed[1]
  - Doing the same thing with dialtone and busy tone detection times
  - Recognizing BBS callers by the unique sound of their modems, and using this to be annoying
  - Surprising other BBS sysops who were themselves trying to call out, by issuing an ATA and dropping them into my BBS's login screen when I heard dialing instead of busy, ringing, or carrier tones
  - Wardialing (I gave up on that forever when the voice from the machine said "911, what is your emergency?" and the usual automated hang-up-and-try-different-random-number routine did not disconnect the call, and instead produced an increasingly-agitated 911 operator)
[1]: A firmware update to the SupraFAXModem v.32bis allowed this timing to be so tight that the phone switch would miss digits, so tuning was in order
Quarrel 7 hours ago [-]
I too tuned my dial tones as short as the exchange would allow. BBSes used to give us busy signals all the time, so modems would redial on a busy signal. It would dial and hang up silly fast, then redial. (The delays by default were not super short between redials, but again, just a value to tune)

A major commercial radio station used to have give aways of music- they’d say they will be “opening the lines soon, first 20 callers win!” My modem was very good at reliably getting me in the first 20 :)

Of course that wouldn’t work without me sitting next to it and a speaker in it!

weinzierl 4 hours ago [-]
All these answers just say what you would assume by applying common sense without any sources or any deeper justification.

I'm sorry I can't you give any of these either but I can give you a completely different explanation which makes a lot more sense to me (having lived at the time).

Early modems were so called acoustic couplers. That meant that they did not connect electrically to the telephone network but acoustically. Mechanically they were a bay you put the handset in and it had a microphone opposite the speaker and speaker opposite the microphone.

So, the speaker was already there[1] when (pure) modems became popular, it's just that the microphone disappeared over time.

[1] And so was all the software infrastructure to support it, like ATM and ATL commands.

mjg59 3 hours ago [-]
There was no good technical reason for acoustic couplers, since they inherently created an additional analogue jump between the phone and the modem. But phone companies argued you couldn't plug anything they didn't provide into their network, and so this was a solution that allowed you to continue using the phone company provided phone.
weinzierl 2 hours ago [-]
Apart from that they were somewhat convenient for home use. Easy to install, easy to use temporarily in a world where most homes just had a single line that had to be shared for voice and computer use.
3 hours ago [-]
glimshe 4 hours ago [-]
I love the Internet (here we are!), but the BBS era ruled. The one thing I'd like my children to experience from the early computer days. Lifelong friends (talked to one of them last week), girlfriends, pirated software, online text games, calling people in real life by their handle... Oh, the memories.

It was the Discord of the 90s.

zavec 3 hours ago [-]
I really wish I had been born 10 or 15 years earlier so I could have experienced it.
mikewarot 1 hours ago [-]
I was visiting Ward Christensen at his home, and he was showing me his BBS, "The Ward Board", and someone was online at the time... after looking at the monitor, and seeing what it was doing, he said "Oh, that's name of user, he's a twit" right before he hit the switch disconnected him.

Unfamiliar with the word, I asked "What's a twit?"

He said... oh, a person that likes to talk online too much, and takes up all the system's time. (There was only one phone line, so of you were on it, nobody else could be)

Years later, I remembered this when I first encountered Twitter. ;-)

glimshe 3 hours ago [-]
Each era has its appeal. I'm sure my children will remember the good old days of Roblox and game modding with buddies on Discord. It's possible that if today's teenagers went back to the BBS days in a DeLorean, they would miss their phone and find it boring.
mitxela 2 hours ago [-]
I remember Garry's Mod and the Wiremod forums.

1/5

jwrallie 1 hours ago [-]
My first PC was an IBM Aptiva from around 1996-97 that had a modem + sound card combo ISA board called Mwave. It was a 28.8 kbps modem, and instead of a low-quality buzzer, the call audio would come from the computer speakers. It was the exact card shown in the Wikipedia page [0].

I was still using a 56.6 kbps modem long after with a Windows XP era machine, it sounded much worse, and usually had a longer negotiation beep sequence that ended up with an actual speed a little bit short of its maximum.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mwave

oivaksef 7 hours ago [-]
Having lived through those years and the many different ways things can go wrong, I can't imagine not having the speaker.
j45 6 hours ago [-]
It's the same as why does a phone have an earpiece.
DougN7 7 hours ago [-]
It let you know if you accidentally called the wrong number because you would hear “hello?” before the screeching started.
curiousObject 6 hours ago [-]
As well as all the other good reasons: modems had speakers because they COULD have speakers, because modems were connected to a network which was designed to safely transmit human-audible analog sound waveforms, which is exactly what cheap speakers are designed to emit.

If we directly connect a speaker to a different data network format, such as Ethernet, we probably will hear nothing useful. Maybe some clicks and pops, or the smell of a blown speaker.

paulstovell 7 hours ago [-]
As a teenager trying to dial in to chat with friends on MSN Messenger at midnight, it was a terrible design feature. Could never sneak past parents!

As a parent now, I wish my kids devices had such a feature.

lm411 6 hours ago [-]
ATL0
throwawaysoxjje 2 hours ago [-]
ATM0 defaulted the speaker to off
smilespray 6 hours ago [-]
The wifi speaker! Log on to the dulcet tones of QAM modulation.
mrheosuper 8 hours ago [-]
>Adding a speaker was cheap and easy. The additional parts were standard, reliable, and inexpensive.

I miss that era. Now if a mlcc can be cut to save a fraction of cent, it sure will be.

Mashimo 1 hours ago [-]
Teenage me was amazed when I found out that I could add an old headphone cable to the 56k modem in order to silence it.
hallgrim 6 hours ago [-]
I will never forget how funny it was when I was maybe 10 years old and my older sister got a call from a friend, I played with the modem software on our windows95 pc and somehow accepted the call on the modem, and suddenly we had a confused “Hello??” coming out of the modem speakers.
jleyank 2 days ago [-]
Sound let you monitor progress and success/failure. It also provided some security against a program phoning home on its own (as long as the speaker was on).
jrmg 7 hours ago [-]
And not just binary success or failure - you also got to know the handshake sound and could predict if it was successfully connecting at high speeds or not - and so quickly hang up and try again if it was going to be slow.
nextaccountic 8 hours ago [-]
Once I dialed the number of my grandma with my modem and my uncle answered the phone. So it also guards for when you inserted the wrong number and some person is actually on the line, and not a computer
tomkarho 2 hours ago [-]
Modems have speakers because they must scream and have no mouths.
browningstreet 6 hours ago [-]
When that high pitch squeal emanated from the modem speaker you’d run across the room and start typing at the BBS because if you didn’t, it would timeout and hang up on you.

Also, if there were issues connecting, you could get a sense from the sounds. Sometimes it told you there were hardware issues afoot and you’d be better off taking a BBS out of the dial rotation for the evening.

(You could redial a group of BBS’ to increase your odds of connecting, as opposed to redialing a singular BBS continually…)

russfink 7 hours ago [-]
Connection protocol codependency: the human follows along to ensure the connection is good because goodness help us you can’t trust the modem to figure it out and get it right every single time alone.
spl757 5 hours ago [-]
I could tell by the sound of the handshake what baud it was negotiating.

edit to say

CONNECT 9600

that was elite back in the day.

edit 2: the sound was completely optional, and could be toggled on and off with an AT command.

GenerWork 8 hours ago [-]
Extremely cool, thanks for sharing! Always interesting to see how people go about solving UX issues with various pieces of physical hardware.
ehnto 4 hours ago [-]
They still do, at least some dev boards do.
gjvc 1 hours ago [-]
daft question
globular-toast 6 hours ago [-]
I wasn't really allowed to use the internet as a teen because it cost money. My parents would never pay for a flat subscription. Luckily I figured out you can disable the speaker in the driver settings, at least you could with ours. Then I preceded to spend half of my teenage life awake at night on the internet after everyone else had gone to bed. This screwed up my sleeping patterns for years.
timonoko 4 hours ago [-]
I had weird multipass modem. It had filters so that you could have 300 bits computer line and telephone conversation at the same time. Not totally useless in remote maintenance type situation.
ChrisArchitect 2 days ago [-]
(2019) OP

If you're going to be posting old things, add dates to them please

Skyfall106 2 days ago [-]
my bad <3
rapist 5 hours ago [-]
did modems change between 2019 and now?
Mashimo 1 hours ago [-]
It's one of the unwritten rules on HN to add dates to older articles.
2 days ago [-]
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 12:25:51 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.