> "But somebody that's making $450,000, $600,000, do they really need that assistance?"
They don't need it, but IMO means testing is generally a huge waste of time and money, creates unfortunate "benefit cliffs" and just creates political division instead of broad universal support.
Make all such benefits universal but also progressively tax wealthy people fairly and it all works itself out.
Grombobulous 29 minutes ago [-]
Right, this logic never made sense when we put it next to all the other government services wealthy people get to use for the same time-of-use price as everyone else.
Nobody suggests that the upper middle class and above start paying extra to use a sidewalk or a sewer but then as soon as other categories of government service come up all of a sudden making society more equitable isn’t fair.
And you’re right about benefit cliffs and the bureaucratic burden of qualification. I think this is a big part of what UBI advocates are trying to say: you can spend money for benefits administrators to make sure there’s no fraud in the system which ends up adding cost and inefficiency when it might be better to just hand out the money to whoever signs up.
readthenotes1 10 minutes ago [-]
Point of use progressive charging works for toll roads, and does for utilities-- where I live, I get charged more If I use more. I know that in Columbia there are also different rates but I'm not sure if it's just for different people, different quality houses or what.
I could be snarky and say that rich people don't use sidewalks:)
yahthatsart 35 minutes ago [-]
Exactly this. Administering means testing is expensive, and fundamentally also leads to a perverse incentive where making more money can actually hurt someone's total benefits.
Also, you know how many people are making $600,000? It's not a lot of people. You know how many parents are making $600,000? It's even fewer people.
It's maybe a hundred kids. I'd rather just soak the cost of paying for 100 kids rather than spending WAY more counting to make sure those specific 100 kids don't get the benefit.
9x39 6 minutes ago [-]
Targeting people to pay and then banning them from the service also doesn't go over well.
Rendered at 05:17:50 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.
They don't need it, but IMO means testing is generally a huge waste of time and money, creates unfortunate "benefit cliffs" and just creates political division instead of broad universal support.
Make all such benefits universal but also progressively tax wealthy people fairly and it all works itself out.
Nobody suggests that the upper middle class and above start paying extra to use a sidewalk or a sewer but then as soon as other categories of government service come up all of a sudden making society more equitable isn’t fair.
And you’re right about benefit cliffs and the bureaucratic burden of qualification. I think this is a big part of what UBI advocates are trying to say: you can spend money for benefits administrators to make sure there’s no fraud in the system which ends up adding cost and inefficiency when it might be better to just hand out the money to whoever signs up.
I could be snarky and say that rich people don't use sidewalks:)
Also, you know how many people are making $600,000? It's not a lot of people. You know how many parents are making $600,000? It's even fewer people.
It's maybe a hundred kids. I'd rather just soak the cost of paying for 100 kids rather than spending WAY more counting to make sure those specific 100 kids don't get the benefit.