NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
▲Mem Is Shutting Down (get.mem.ai)
dvt 4 hours ago [-]
First of all, I really do think people got a bit carried away with the "ChatGPT, summarize this email" meme. AI really is a revolutionary technology, but low hanging fruit like note-taking, summarization, etc. are not even remotely a killer product.

Second, I also think that (outside of search), we'll look at the chatting interface of today's AI tools in 5 years and laugh at how antiquated they seem.

Finally, Obsidian (not to mention Apple Notes) is free. So to be competitive here, your value prop has to be an absolute home run. I'm never going to root against fellow entrepreneurs, but this just seems like a more pricy, maybe more stylish Obsidian (without all the plugin ecosystem? and you also need a browser extension?). Obviously, hindsight is 20-20, but if I were to release a productivity app today, I would do a few things:

1) Open Source it. Especially in the age of agents, people want to make sure that no shenanigans are being done with sensitive data, especially when it involves private notes.

2) Dual license it. Folks have done this since Red Hat, and I think dual licensing for personal & professional use (or have a revenue cutoff like Unreal or Unity) is the move.

3) Create a plugin ecosystem around it. I think the great thing about agents is that even non-technical folks can come up with stuff and vibe-code a plugin. Incentivize people to do this and build a community.

abeindoria 4 hours ago [-]
>AI really is a revolutionary technology, but low hanging fruit like note-taking, summarization, etc. are not even remotely a killer product.

I am frequently baffled how Chinese labs (Like Alibaba Qwen) tend to make better 'marketing' material than a lot of what OAI/Anthropic does, especially Anthropic.

The Qwen3.8-Max release trailer was one of the better examples of it.[1] Meanwhile Anthropic releases tend to be very dense and maybe a 20-30 second teaser of an abstract beige flower. I get it, they aim a _ton_ towards people who release their release reports and system cards, but at what point do you start marketing to the everyday people if your goal really is "Beneficial/Benevolent AI for everyone."

---

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CKlK-KDFKjM

leetrout 19 minutes ago [-]
Wow that video makes me insanely jealous. I wish more places had that attitude about how these onew tools can affect positive change in our life and in our workday.

In my corner of the world we were hit with the expectation that we are pushing up to 10 things forward at the same time since agents can operate in parallel.

I also realize the juxtaposition of that video coming out of a Chinese company and the slave labor used across the country. Still a guy can dream.

nottorp 2 hours ago [-]
You forget OpenAI and Anthropic have to threaten humanity in each press release.

I suppose the Chinese sound more optimistic than that?

ifwinterco 48 minutes ago [-]
Yeah it does help when unlike American big tech you don't go out of your way to sound comically evil and sinister for no particular reason
xnorswap 2 hours ago [-]
They are absolutely a killer product, but they're one that is effectively baked into the core offerings of the AI model providers, they're not viable as a business by themselves given that.

Summarisation is one of the biggest features that makes the AI providers apps killer apps in their own right. The ability to ingest arbitrary unstructured data, digest it, and return it in an more familiar format is a massive time-save and huge productivity boost.

lumini 2 hours ago [-]
A chat interface is simply a design for continuous interactions. Not much has changed since the earliest IM tools, and I don't think there is much need to design something different, though it could certainly be optimized.

> Open Source it.

I don't think every piece of software is open source today, nor do I think it should be. Data security is a valid and critical concern, but that doesn't automatically call for open sourcing, right? __In the age of agents__, going open source also means your work will be copied and rebranded within an hour or two.

I agree that note-taking and summarization shouldn't be hot topics today. Solutions existed before GPT-3, and they weren't that bad. Still, I believe AI apps should sell a better experience for specific use cases, just like non-AI software. An ecosystem helps, but if the whole pitch is around plugins, you are essentially selling a platform—and that platform is unlikely to attract good builders.

ignoramous 2 hours ago [-]
> ... every piece of software is open source today, nor do I think it should be. Data security ...

Open source is a great way to get the attention of technical users, especially the ones who use LLMs for other tasks, already.

DocTomoe 2 hours ago [-]
> __In the age of agents__, going open source also means your work will be copied and rebranded within an hour or two.

That argument has become me after the x-craft series of vibecoded apps, which appear to be functional to the level I used the 'closed-sourced' tools.

ignoramous 2 hours ago [-]
> ... every piece of software is open source today, nor do I think it should be. Data security ...

Open source is a great way to get the attention of technical users, who use LLMs for other tasks, already.

dlisboa 2 hours ago [-]
> Second, I also think that (outside of search), we'll look at the chatting interface of today's AI tools in 5 years and laugh at how antiquated they seem.

All of the main AI companies have speech-to-text. You can interface with them solely by talking to them, which is how every sci-fi technology ever worked.

That people don’t do use that as much isn’t that chat is antiquated but it has qualities of its own. Being forced to think a little bit before writing a prompt comes out cleaner and more efficient. Much like planning a presentation before doing it.

solarkraft 2 hours ago [-]
> Especially in the age of agents, people want to make sure that no shenanigans are being done with sensitive data, especially when it involves private notes

That’s one key part, the other is that everyone is a developer now, so you’d better make software that’s customizable in some way. Opening the code ensures this pretty well (a good plugin system is even better but you can do both).

vbezhenar 3 hours ago [-]
What's wrong with chatting interface?

Google Search didn't change since 1997. It's just textbox.

Chat interface probably should stay the same.

My biggest issue is how primitive text editor is. For a trillion-dollar company, they could make it work better with their beloved markdown format. Tripe-backquote will work when I'm typing new message, but it won't work when I'm editing message. It's also unnecessarily smart, so I often have issues editing single-backquoted strings. Ideally I'd prefer to keep all markdown markup intact and just add proper styling on the fly, as I type it, so I can actually edit markup if necessary. For example I can type ``` in ChatGPT and it instantly switches to code editor. But what if I wanted to type ```bash? It doesn't let me. Also I hate that there's no way to make <Enter> insert newlines. Most of my messages are multiline and I sometimes press <Enter> just to send unfinished message and waste tokens.

But yeah, outside of that little rant, I think that textedit UI is pretty much essential and will probably stay relevant for a long time.

DocTomoe 2 hours ago [-]
> Google Search didn't change since 1997. It's just textbox.

Google Search changed tremendously since 1997. Yes, it's still a textbox. But commands changed and disappeared all the time.

"Google Search didn't change' is only true if you used it as a 'here's a keyword, give me random results' box.

frevib 3 hours ago [-]
Standardnotes is open source, has a free plan and is end-to-end encrypted.

https://standardnotes.com/plans

https://github.com/standardnotes

badsectoracula 3 hours ago [-]
> 1) Open Source it. 2) Dual license it. 3) Create a plugin ecosystem around it [..] folks can come up with stuff and vibe-code a plugin

But then where does the money come from?

mrweasel 4 hours ago [-]
Nothing against Mem, or people trying to built something, but this will become a problem for the larger AI companies. Much of their current revenue is coming from smaller startups building product on top of e.g. ChatGPT. While useful, I question if these smaller players will survive, especially if they have to pay the actual cost of their token usage.

On the other hand, OpenAI is releasing Dot, so maybe they'll just service those customers directly in the future, or at least some of them.

zombot 43 minutes ago [-]
The big labs let the small startups explore the risky stuff while getting paid for it. And then cut out the middle man for the experiments that don't fail. Win-win.
maplet 8 hours ago [-]
Reminds me of kepano's File Over App [1] philosophy.

> Apps are ephemeral, but your files have a chance to last.

1: https://stephango.com/file-over-app

talmr 6 hours ago [-]
I’ve been talking to (small/mid) business owners, consultants, etc.

Many of them say they don’t care about integrations or AI.

itake 5 hours ago [-]
yeah... I had this idea of buying a small/mid business, giving it better life with AI (basically P/E strategy), but...

I realized that better/cheaper SaaS tools probably wont move the needle much for these companies. Saving $200/mo on a self-hosted CRM or Notion isn't going to cut more lawns.

qeternity 4 hours ago [-]
You mentioned giving it a better life with AI and then just talked about self hosting some tools...
spiderfarmer 5 hours ago [-]
Yeah that's true. But that's because you shouldn't sell them a technology, you should sell them productivity.

I am overwhelmed with demand from business owners that recommend me to each other, because I build stuff that saves them one important thing: time.

So much so that I'm not able to focus on my own products at the moment.

nevon 4 hours ago [-]
What's an example of something you've built to save small/medium business owners time (presumably within the context of applying AI), out of curiosity?
resiros 5 hours ago [-]
Just like no one cared about the internet, they cared about more sales. SMB owners care about having more time or making more money (i.e. automating things with AI).
FinnLobsien 1 hours ago [-]
My theory on this is that Mem existed in a weird middle ground:

1. Note taking as a mechanism to organize one's knowledge or learn things faster is (in my experience) largely useful because the process is manual. The linking between notes and conscientious note-taking is useful because it forces your brain to be attentive and resurfaces knowledge you may have forgotten.

When AI does the connecting, you lose part of that, which the personal knowledge management crowd probably didn't fully connect.

2. ChatGPT memory, AI meeting recorders, and similar apps united the more utilitarian aspect of "remember stuff I need to know" in tools you use for direct work so you didn't need a separate AI note-taking app.

-

I do applaud the Mem team for making a genuine attempt at something genuinely interesting and new.

NoboruWataya 2 hours ago [-]
I don't really understand the variety and complexity of note taking apps that have emerged the last few years. Taking notes has to be the simplest thing in the world, why over-engineer it like this? I used to use Joplin, recently I've realised that a text editor + git gives me everything I need.
futuraperdita 10 hours ago [-]
Roughly $29 million in VC went to this product.
kubb 4 hours ago [-]
I wish I was better at talking, coaxing and getting rapport. That’s the limitation preventing me from getting something more out of life.

Money is lying around these days, and you can just legally take it by duping people, but you have to know how to dupe. I never learned this elementary skill for life success.

syshyk 3 hours ago [-]
Forget about all the possible problems that problem solvers work on, ignore all that, sell the dream and forget your morals.

No thanks.

kubb 3 hours ago [-]
We have to ignore our morals anyway to survive. Might as well get paid for it.
lukan 3 hours ago [-]
And who or what is forcing you to? Do you claim all other people do the same to survive?
kubb 14 minutes ago [-]
Not all, but so many do. We eat meat, work on brain rotting tech, pollute the environment, use way too much fossil energy, manufacture need for useless crap.

In comparison, cheating a VC out of a couple million is mild.

VladVladikoff 9 hours ago [-]
What is the product? I’ve never heard of it before

Edit: looked it up, it’s an AI note taking app from what I can tell.

freakynit 9 hours ago [-]
What da absoute fck!! $29 million for this? Seriously?
neya 7 hours ago [-]
We as engineers look at it and think about the effort needed to build something like that. Marketers look at the idea and think about numbers, what could be and slap some nice graphs on it, which is what VC firms like to see. They don't care if you can scale the backend to 100M users. To them, engineering is just another aspect that money can solve, so they throw more money at it later (such as hiring more engineers, getting a CTO who's also good at making powerpoint slides, etc)
Brian_K_White 4 hours ago [-]
When I was a kid I had a job with a plumber & general contractor. We were sitting behind the van having morning coffee & hard roll before starting one day and there was a new plastic paint bucket on the ground with an aluminum ring fit inside it that held a few tools. It was kind of neat how it was just a simple single part punched out of a single flat sheet and made use of a common 5 gallon paint bucket and togethr it made something kinda sorta useful.

He said it cost about $20 (in like 1992 dollars) and I was gobsmacked and insensed, flabbergasted. Whatva scam, $20 just for that? It's just a standard paint bucket and a single flat punched part, not even stamped into a 3d shape just a flat sheet part!

The owner was not bothered at all and I didn't understand why not. He asked me what I thought it should cost.

Obviously when you start to add up all the things that go into even something as dirt simple as that, it adds up fast and you have a hard time getting it down to $100 by the time it's sitting on a shelf at home depot.

We're both right. If that thing was popular enough to take advantage of real mass production, then sure, it could be very cheap, because the buckets are already mass produced because they are used for many things (minus custom labelling), and the ring could be rolling off a punch by the hundreds per minute. But anything short of real mass production and there are just a lot of people who each need a dollar from each unit. If the object was worth $20 for him in usefulness, or he couldn't make one for $20, then it's worth it. It would probably cost more than that to tell me to make one as his employee, and we had the tools and means to fabricate something like that, and I'm good at stuff like that. The engineer asessment of the value is both true and not.

But it sure is easy to only see one tiny slice of a whole picture.

guessmyname 8 hours ago [-]
Well, it has shutdown. You can vibe-slop an identical app/service to get another US$25M or more, depending on how ambitious and skilled you are at shit-talking… I mean, depends on how good you are at navigating VC meetings with persuasive talk. For better or worse, US$25M is not a lot compared to the extravagant sums of money thrown around Silicon Valley venture capital groups.
ChuckSneed 7 hours ago [-]
Wont work that easy now that AI bubble has popped. Though there would be a new bubble in yet another thing soon, so you can position yourself for that.
wk_end 6 hours ago [-]
The AI bubble has popped?
jurgenburgen 4 hours ago [-]
Far too early to call it though this autumn has been tough on neoclouds.
userbinator 8 hours ago [-]
You can vibe-slop an identical app/service to get another US$25M or more

Probably not, now that everyone realises they could do it themselves with AI.

xattt 9 hours ago [-]
Not familiar with the VC process. What happens with this? Is it written off, or do founders become metaphorical indentured servants?
Aurornis 9 hours ago [-]
> or do founders become metaphorical indentured servants?

VCs invest in the company. They put money into the company and get equity in the company in return.

It’s not a loan to the founders. So don’t worry, they’re not indentured servants and everyone, including the VCs, knew this was a possible outcome. In VC it’s actually the most likely outcome because most companies don’t become big successes or even become valuable stable businesses.

What happens next: The remaining assets and liabilities will be settled up. Any remaining cash goes to the owners (equity), generally with some preference to paying back most recent investors first up (preference).

If the founders performed well and the investors believed they were doing good work that didn’t pan out due to market conditions or bad luck, they may be interested in investing with those founders again later. Or they may be sour and not want to talk to them. I’ve seen more of the former than the latter. Most VCs try to avoid getting bad reputations so they’ll make an effort to stay on good terms with founders.

paimapi 9 hours ago [-]
VCs bet widely and hope they nab a big one that'll net billions in equity. Tossing a few million here or there to seed the field is part of the strategy (though you'd hope they're making smart bets and not just letting nepo babies through or getting swept up by an adept sales pitch but I've heard a lot of stories otherwise)
LastTrain 8 hours ago [-]
The data users shared with Mem gets sold to the highest bidder.
weird-eye-issue 9 hours ago [-]
It's just simply a total loss, that's what happens the majority of times in these investments and they know that going into it
BetterThanSober 7 hours ago [-]
Given enough money and analysts of average competency acting in good faith, VC will almost always comes ahead

See old YC stat https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/yc-stats/ one jackpot is enough to offsets the failure

wonnage 5 hours ago [-]
VC returns have actually been terrible. https://www.cambridgeassociates.com/insight/us-pe-vc-benchma...

The folks running the funds do well, but as an asset class it's absolutely foolish

irjustin 7 hours ago [-]
Many of the responses aren't taking you seriously:

- It is written off as an investment loss for that particular fund (commonly VCs have Fund 1, 2, 3).

Then everyone moves on with their lives.

aizk 8 hours ago [-]
To VCs this is like a scratch off ticket.
kphorn 9 hours ago [-]
This is exactly the answer I came to this comment section for
alexpadula 9 hours ago [-]
Saw that on Linkedin. "We've raised $29M to date from the OpenAI Startup Fund, Andreessen Horowitz (a16z), Floodgate, Unusual Ventures, and other amazing investors."
cebert 8 hours ago [-]
I cannot believe that they were able to get $29 million in VC. There’s no moat here.
kiranp 5 hours ago [-]
I think they got funded in 2022, and at that time no one knew that the world would evolve like this.
nylonstrung 6 hours ago [-]
What an embarrassment given what Obsidian and Siyuan (which I like even better) have been able to achieve with such limited resources
skybrian 8 hours ago [-]
Do you have a source?
skeledrew 9 hours ago [-]
Happy user of org-mode for the past 10 years. Nothing else is a flexible IMO.
keyle 8 hours ago [-]
Only 10? /s
pulkitsh1234 8 hours ago [-]
I have been building a note taking app which can launch Pi agents, running fully locally, backed by markdown: https://solipsist.sh/
throw03172019 7 hours ago [-]
This looks pretty cool actually. Great work
mellosouls 2 hours ago [-]
Best wishes to the mem team - good to see what looks like a smooth and well-signposted export process as they close.
tulo 1 hours ago [-]
Nice that they gave a 60-day export window, though shutdowns like this are why I keep long-term notes in plain local Markdown/SQLite.
privacyishuman 10 hours ago [-]
Is there any cross platform open source notes app with as good UI as Apple Notes?
orsenthil 10 hours ago [-]
Obsidian.
snowbeing 10 hours ago [-]
i would argue that obsidian has a better UI than apple notes, but it unfortunately isn't open source.
Grombobulous 8 hours ago [-]
I feel like the massive difficulty in self-hosting a sync server is intentional sabotage to make you pay for their cloud service.

I can understand the economic reasons why but I don’t love it.

bryanhogan 2 hours ago [-]
Isn't being able to sync your own plain files the most simple thing to do, how is this intentional sabotage?
Grombobulous 1 hours ago [-]
See for yourself. It’s nowhere near as easy as it sounds.

First follow these steps:

https://github.com/vrtmrz/obsidian-livesync#1-choose-a-synch...

Then set up your first device:

https://github.com/vrtmrz/obsidian-livesync/blob/main/docs/q...

Non-intentional sabotage would be Obsidian providing the server and supporting it as a first-class option where you just paste in your server URL into the app without the need for a convoluted third-party plugin.

stavros 7 hours ago [-]
I've never tried to set it up, but how difficult can it be? Won't an LLM just set it up for you?
Grombobulous 1 hours ago [-]
I don’t think that expecting end users to finish the software themselves with an LLM is a very good user experience.

Check my other comment in this thread, see the setup steps for yourself. I think they’re way harder than they should be for something as simple as a notes app, and it shouldn’t require a third-party plugin in the first place. They should just provide a server docker container and then the app should let you connect to an arbitrary URL without this very long and technical process.

Yes you can just use a cloud folder for storage (iCloud only on iOS) but that’s not the full feature set including live sync.

_ink_ 5 hours ago [-]
On an iOS device the options are limited. On Android it's fairly easy. This made me stay with Android when my phone died.
stavros 5 hours ago [-]
Oh, I thought you meant the server itself, not the clients.
rembal 4 hours ago [-]
Obsidian is purely file based, a you can use anything that syncs files (w.g. Google Drive) , but you need a shared filesystem across multiple apps for that.
Grombobulous 1 hours ago [-]
This is not 100% true as features like live sync require couchdb.
archargelod 8 hours ago [-]
beware: Obsidian runs on Electron - slow, sluggish, memory wasting piece of garbage.
bryanhogan 2 hours ago [-]
The work that Kepano and his team have put into making Obsidian perform well has been incredible, even writing their own open-source replacement for Mermaid, Pele.

The performance of Obsidian is generally good, but be aware of what plugins you add. This critique reminds me of people who hate on games using a specific game engine when that never is the deciding matter.

nottorp 1 hours ago [-]
> people who hate on games using a specific game engine

Unity has evolved in time (or perhaps the other engines have devolved) but back when it was new you knew an Unity game is going to kill your laptop battery 2-3x faster than a handwritten game.

Case in point, I could play the first x-com "reinvention" 2x longer on my laptop than most unity games.

konart 5 hours ago [-]
>slow, sluggish

This part is not true though. Unless you have some 20 y.o. hardware.

dieulot 5 hours ago [-]
I have a then-€1200 base MacBook Air from early 2020, Obsidian is a dog on it.
justinclift 4 hours ago [-]
Do you use many extensions/plugins/similar with it?
egeozcan 8 hours ago [-]
That's why my gut tells me that somebody somewhere must have vibe-coded a 100% compatible rust based replacement.
smahs 5 hours ago [-]
The core of Obsidian is CodeMirror 6, which is hard to replace for its live preview feature. No rust editor and GUI toolkit even comes close to CM6/browser. But electron can be replaced.
nicce 5 hours ago [-]
Everyone can vibecode their own. At least I did.
OlaProis 4 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
BetterThanSober 7 hours ago [-]
Just use Zed /s
stevenxlee 3 hours ago [-]
glitchc 10 hours ago [-]
Yes, check out Standard Notes.
Onavo 8 hours ago [-]
Joplin, it's the only one that's end to end encrypted by default and reuses your existing cloud storage services instead of requiring a custom server. It also supports custom extensions and plugins.
vunderba 8 hours ago [-]
+1 for Joplin - but unless something's changed in the past few years, I can't stand the way they structure your notes.

If you already have a well organized folder/subfolder of markdown notes, Joplin takes'em and shoves them into a SQLite table with UUID names, attached media is also renamed and stored under something like `~/.config/joplin-desktop/resources`.

Makes it very difficult to use your existing notes with bash tools, etc. once Joplin has ingested them.

stavros 7 hours ago [-]
I'm fairly sure that an LLM can one-shot you a FUSE driver to expose the notes as a filesystem.
vunderba 7 hours ago [-]
Apparently it's been attempted before as well:

https://github.com/CalebJohn/joplin-filesystem

stavros 7 hours ago [-]
Oh nice, though this is read-only. Maybe I'll write a read/write one, as I do use Joplin.
inopinatus 7 hours ago [-]
Fenced gardens are a -5 for any note taking utility. If the tool can't/won't use a filesystem to organize documents as files in folders, I assume the author was a moron. I don't mind if it has its own structured storage model as well for whatever reason, but skipping out on the most foundational persistence structure is an instant fail, being (amongst other sins) a mismatch for work trees. And import/export is friction, not an exemption.
iLoveOncall 2 hours ago [-]
You must be trolling. I would rather use Markdown files in any text editor rather than Apple Notes. It's the most barebones note-taking software I can imagine.
nxtfari 4 hours ago [-]
Mem was so exciting to me when I first heard about it. Unfortunately they just shipped the most compelling features too slowly, and had too much you couldn’t try behind the sub. Didn’t get traction with me and I imagine a lot of people felt similar.

Wonder if we’ll see the scavengers of Bending Spoons descending shortly.

khizar0 3 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
charcircuit 36 minutes ago [-]
I don't understand why it can't just be read only forever. It's just notes.
ziofill 7 hours ago [-]
Ha, I didn't know about this. A few months ago I built an app to capture fleeting thoughts without breaking you flow: https://getquicklog.com/
andsoitis 5 hours ago [-]
> difficult decision

What made it a difficult decision?

pelcg 10 hours ago [-]
Does anyone still use Mem? Haven't heard from them in a while until now.
skeledrew 10 hours ago [-]
That's why they're shutting down.
orliesaurus 9 hours ago [-]
Surprised they lasted this long TBFH.
ares623 9 hours ago [-]
And on the horizon, I saw a pale, white horse. And its rider was Death.
weikju 9 hours ago [-]
Queue Google/etc buying up all that data on the cheap for AI training...
iLoveOncall 2 hours ago [-]
Seeing the AI bubble slowly deflate is truly a joy.
cowpig 8 hours ago [-]
Odds your memories will be sold to Mercor?
jocelyner 7 hours ago [-]
[dead]
sreekanth850 8 hours ago [-]
This show how brainless and broken is investor ecosystem. How the hell they invest 29 million in a product with saturated market with 1 product launching every day?
dvt 4 hours ago [-]
It's working as intended, many small bets and a few will hit big. 29 million is nothing in the grand scheme of things.
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 12:17:59 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.