There really aren't the level of formal models in biology that would are viable for empirical validation and formal verification
oytis 1 hours ago [-]
Biology is outside of mathematic's and logic's realms
2 hours ago [-]
MeteorMarc 2 hours ago [-]
Yes, high on the wishlist: quantumgravity, room temperature superconductivity, majorana quantum computing. Maybe physicists also should make their millennial list of open problems.
barrenko 2 hours ago [-]
Hoping this births a textbook or two somehow.
arendtio 2 hours ago [-]
On the one hand, I really look forward to progress in physics to enable Star Trek-like technologies, but on the other hand, I wonder if we should solve our global conflicts first.
I mean, wouldn't it be great if AI could lead us to a world of lasting peace, prosperity, and happiness?
noir_lord 2 hours ago [-]
> I mean, wouldn't it be great if AI could lead us to a world of lasting peace, prosperity, and happiness?
Not convinced that is within the capabilities of any AI without it doing things we would in fact not want it to do to us as a species.
We seem to be built for conflict and I'm not sure that what is left when that is removed is still us.
> Let me tell you something about Hew-mons, Nephew. They're a wonderful, friendly people, as long as their bellies are full and their holosuites are working. But take away their creature comforts, deprive them of food, sleep, sonic showers, put their lives in jeopardy over an extended period of time and those same friendly, intelligent, wonderful people... will become as nasty and as violent as the most bloodthirsty Klingon. You don't believe me? Look at those faces. Look in their eyes. (Quark from the always brilliant DS9).
Yeah I'm cynical <waves at history>.
stareatgoats 1 hours ago [-]
OK, I'll bite: I find little support in history for the theory that conflict is inevitable because humans have an intrinsic desire or inherent nature that drives us to go to war. War is what people have turned to in roughly two circumstances, none of which are or will be ubiquitously present:
1. when (the leaders of some) some belligerent tribe, nation or coalition etc perceive that they can promote their interests by going to war without risks that at first blush will outweigh the gains.
2. when some (the leaders of some) tribe, nation or coalition etc can credibly anticipate that they are about to be attacked and then go to war, because 'attack is the best defense'.
Proof abounds in history that war is not inevitable. One example: peoples all over Europe that used to engage in constant war with their neighbors in the next valley, next district, next-door nation, over hunting-, grazing-, market- and raw material opportunities have ceased to do so even if they are essentially the same peoples.
It's of course essentially just simple cost/benefit analysis, not blind human nature.
danmaz74 2 hours ago [-]
The major source of global conflicts is the scarcity of resources. A breakthrough in physics+engineering that allowed anybody anywhere to produce usable energy (eg electricity) at will wouldn't guarantee a conflict-free world, but it would be the biggest step in that direction I could think of.
Timwi 1 hours ago [-]
So true. Most major 20th/21st-century conflicts were about oil. With climate change looming, experts are predicting water wars.
93po 2 hours ago [-]
I posted a nearly identical comment and thought I was having a stroke reading yours because I didn't remember using the very similar but different wording you did, haha.
keybored 1 hours ago [-]
A rich country toppling a weak country doesn’t happen because the rich country is poor. It’s because of the institutional logic of profit maximization.
Just to say that it’s more than just scarcity of resources.
simmanian 2 hours ago [-]
I hope one day we would have formally verifiable governance structures that foster peace, prosperity, and happiness.
bijowo1676 2 hours ago [-]
Below is a list of conflicts created, funded, armed, and backed by the USA. If you want to stop "global conflicts", you need to look in the mirror and understand who is the problem, before you propose any solutions, like stalling Physics research as a solution to global conflicts.
You need to have crystal clear clarity about who exactly is the Threat to the global peace.
Argentina, 1976, CIA backed coup
Brazil, 1964, CIA backed coup
Bolivia, 1971, CIA backed coup
Chile, 1973, CIA backed coup
Cuba, 1950s, CIA backed Batista
Dominican Republic, 1902–1924, US military occupation
Ecuador, 1961, CIA backed coup
El Salvador, 1980s, CIA funded dictatorship
Grenada, 1979, CIA destabilised country
Guatemala, 1954, CIA backed coup
Haiti, 1915–1934, US military occupation
Haiti, 1990, CIA backed coup
Honduras, 1980s, CIA backed coup
Nicaragua, 1979, US backed dictator
Nicaragua, 1982–1989, CIA funded Contras
Panama, 1941, US backed coup
Panama, 1989, US military invasion
Paraguay, 1954–1989, CIA funded dictatorship
Peru, 1980–2000, CIA funded dictatorship
Uruguay, 1973, CIA funded dictatorship
Ghana, 1966, CIA backed coup
Chad, 1982, CIA funded dictatorship
DRC, 1961, CIA backed coup
Philippines, 1965–1986, CIA funded dictatorship
South Korea, 1945, Outlawed PRK government
Cambodia, 1970, CIA backed coup
Indonesia, 1965, CIA backed coup
Laos, 1957, Multiple CIA coups
Greece, 1947, CIA backed junta
Italy, 1948–1996, CIA corrupted elections
Iran, 1953, CIA backed coup
Syria, 1949, CIA backed coup
Syria, 2013, US drone strikes
Niger & Sahel, 2013–2024, Counterterrorism drone deployments
Somalia, 2013–2026, Airstrikes and raids
Pakistan, 2013–2018, Covert drone strikes
Iraq, 2014–2026, Counter ISIS intervention
Syria, 2014–2026, Sustained military airstrikes
Yemen & Red Sea, 2014–2026, Naval and airstrikes
Libya, 2015–2019, Renewed bombing campaigns
Bolivia, 2019, Disputed coup backing
Iran, 2020–2026, Direct military strikes
Gaza Sector, 2023-2026, US backed and armed genocide of Palestinians in Gaza
Venezuela, 2025–2026, Raid capturing Maduro
Nigeria, 2025–2026, Joint military operations
Ecuador, 2026, Joint border airstrikes
jsLavaGoat 51 minutes ago [-]
based
34987349068 22 minutes ago [-]
[dead]
93po 2 hours ago [-]
I think global conflicts are largely due to scarcity and a desire for control over resources. If AI makes everything significantly more abundant, I think it would in turn massively reduce global conflicts.
awestroke 2 hours ago [-]
And how do you propose to do that?
amelius 2 hours ago [-]
Let AI invent the Holodeck.
“All of humanity's problems stem from man's inability to sit quietly in a room alone.”
― Blaise Pascal
runarberg 2 hours ago [-]
AI won‘t. AI as a project is asserting power into the hands of a handful owners of capital, at a time when global inequality was already a massive driver of conflict and harm to humanity in general. AI will only make this problem worse.
Additionally, look at how AI is used in global conflict today, e.g. its role in the Gaza genocide, and you must conclude that this technology does not have a good track record for global peace, quite the contrary.
Axsuul 2 hours ago [-]
Why not both at the same time?
nitroedge 2 hours ago [-]
Why not build space technologies to depart the global conflicts?
goatlover 1 hours ago [-]
And go live where else? Mars is harsher than Antartica and warp drives depend on whether physics allows a feasible design that doesn't require too much energy. And even then, where is a habitable planet for humans out there?
nitroedge 1 hours ago [-]
Just outside of Earth's atmosphere, in a new colony station, then vacation on Mars in a bubble utopia paradise there. Baby steps :)
dist-epoch 4 hours ago [-]
I see the pi=3 theorem missing, I'll add it.
wren6991 3 hours ago [-]
You're thinking of engineeringlib. In physicslib it's 22/7
rcr-anti 3 hours ago [-]
While still possible, the proof exploiting a bug is vanishingly small now. Following a few bugs and bad proofs this year, there are a number of different implementations, in different languages, and with different levels of proofs of their consistency. con-leche and con-ron are the heavy hitters, with consistency proofs of themselves. So for RH to be false, there'd have to be a bug in all the kernels that affects both the consistency proofs and the RH proof itself.
magicalhippo 1 hours ago [-]
Since I'm not terribly familiar with Lean, math folks are generally satisfied the provided proof encodes the RH correctly I presume?
edit: I need to learn to read, that's the first part of their statement.
The statement of the Riemann Hypothesis is correct. This statement is part of Mathlib: RiemannHypothesis and has been carefully vetted by experts in Lean and number theory.
brooke2k 1 hours ago [-]
The statement of RH that it proves is taken directly from Mathlib, so it's extremely well-vetted and longstanding (from my understanding).
psychoslave 2 hours ago [-]
Even exploiting bugs would be interesting and constructive, as it would reveal some things to fix.
Timwi 1 hours ago [-]
Well yeah, if we can find the bug(s). The big worry is that we might overlook the bug and go on our merry way assuming the claimed results are true when they're not. (I don't see that happening in the case of the Riemann hypothesis, but the same worry exists for all proofs that exist only in the form of Lean code, such as the massive dump from OpenAI.)
davidguetta 2 hours ago [-]
how unreasonable is it to think that during the ai assited claude bruteforce process, it bruteforced also the kernel and built on a randomly found logical inconsistency
grandpa 35 minutes ago [-]
This is covered in point 4 of the linked post. The exported raw proof has been checked by several different kernels, not just one.
dev_dan_2 30 minutes ago [-]
very, due to the precautions explained in the link. For example, they used multiple kernels with different implementations etc.
whimsicalism 2 hours ago [-]
unreasonable
quantumspandex 57 minutes ago [-]
As unreasonable as assuming all human's peer reviewed proofs to be incorrect due to an error collectively missed by all humans.
luke5441 2 hours ago [-]
"This year" hints at them all being created this year. Does that mean they have all been created via LLM from the same corpus?
whimsicalism 2 hours ago [-]
is it still possible absent a flaw in the hardware model for con-leche?
layer8 2 hours ago [-]
The underlying type theory could theoretically turn out to be unsound.
bwestergard 17 minutes ago [-]
Which is perhaps not such a far-fetched possibility?
While I have not studied this topic enough to really understand _how_, but I've been told that type systems laid out in frequently cited papers by the likes of Girard and Martin-Löf were found to be unsound more than a decade after publication. These issues were then "patched", so to speak.
Can anyone better versed in type theory explain how likely that is for the type system of Lean?
thejokeisonme 4 hours ago [-]
A fake refutation of the Collatz conjecture already got through one of these independent checkers in the past.
What's harder, proving GRH or finding a way to get through every checker (which aren't as independent as they are sometimes touted to be)?
In this case there was a human expert in the loop so it's much less likely the model hacked its way through the problem without the expert noticing. But the statement as written has 4 points, none of which rests on the human involvement. So I don't like that they claim full confidence based on those points.
In short, Lean has formally verified checkers now, and the RH proof was checked with them. So any such soundness hole would have to be exploited in the correctness proofs of the checkers, which is a much smaller attack surface than the RH formalization.
bertonvv 3 hours ago [-]
I might be asking a stupid question, but how are the checkers formally verified? Do they use another theorem prover that is not Lean?
sigbottle 3 hours ago [-]
It's turtles all the way down (what if every x86 and ARM chip has some obscure ISA exploit that agents are silently using that we don't know about?) but the idea is that while you can't remove absolute dependence, you can remove chains of dependencies and keep making it smaller and smaller w/ reductionism
3uruiueijjj 2 hours ago [-]
You can keep writing simpler checkers that check the more complicated checkers. But at some point you will have to give up and say "this checker looks correctly implemented (to us) and gives the results we expect on all our tests."
Depending on how the checker works, you might be able to run it on itself. But that doesn't say much; maybe it only approves itself due to a bug.
thechao 2 hours ago [-]
There's multiple independent kernels, run on distinct hardware; they're trusted because they're small.
Betelbuddy 3 hours ago [-]
Checkers all the way down?
computerfriend 3 hours ago [-]
Yo dawg, I heard you like formal verification...
Betelbuddy 2 hours ago [-]
Dont get me started...hate it...
YetAnotherNick 3 hours ago [-]
One thing that every manual/automated verification relies on is the consistency of ZFC + few inaccessible cardinals. I mean while humans have carefully thought about the flaws in that for century and didn't find any, it's not grounded in any clear reasoning why it is consistent.
Not at all saying it is inconsistent, but I personally find the liberal use of introducing inaccessible cardinals axioms a bit concerning.
jeremyjh 3 hours ago [-]
Much of mathematics relies on these axioms. There is nothing special about the dependency of proof checkers or verification of this particular hypothesis. What is the purpose of this statement in this context?
ironborn123 3 hours ago [-]
Most natural problems like RH, twin primes, etc dont fundamentally rely on the inaccessible cardinals. Any problem that depends on them, there is much debate whether they can be called natural.
Many problems may not require even full zfc. zf, peano or even weaker may be enough.
There are also many theorem provers not just lean. lean depends on type theory, but metamath for example depends on zfc directly.
It may be a good but likely tedious exercise to convince yourself by translating the current proof to a zfc dependent prover.
ogogmad 3 hours ago [-]
It's possible that the question of consistency is too abstract to judge its significance. Why?
(1) A lot of the mathematics that was done in the 18th century was
obviously inconsistent and yet still useful.
(2) Trying to verify logical consistency of a theory is basically impossible
because of Goedel's 2nd Incompleteness Theorem.
Hitting a wall like this makes me think we're asking the wrong question.
dev_dan_2 20 minutes ago [-]
> But the statement as written has 4 points, none of which rests on the human involvement.
The theory and implementation of Lean is very much so a result of human involvement, on a massive scale even. Just because it is something repeatable does not lower that in any way.
Distrust of LLM output should not turn into distrust of automation, I think. The former I totally get (and deeply hold myself), the later is likely to hold one back - imagine banning calculators because there is not human in the loop, to make an extreme example.
trio8453 4 hours ago [-]
We need to give Levent a lot of credit for this. As much as we talk about Claude proving it, Levent seems to have a rare talent for getting the most out of it.
kingstnap 3 hours ago [-]
Should we though? Is working at anthropic and using unrestricted unreleased models really fair?
If everyone got to do that then we would really know how rare his talent is. But we don't, and he doesn't post his prompts or workflows. So how can you be so sure.
If he was at least posting his prompts we could acknowledge that. But honestly I'm not going to give him the benefit of the doubt on this. Highly accomplished and successful yes, but uniquely talent who knows.
lukeify 2 hours ago [-]
> Should we though? Is working at anthropic and using unrestricted unreleased models really fair?
Most of the discoveries in the last 2000 years were made by individuals who were born into wealth, had the right set of circumstances, or were blessed by the powers that be at the time.
Imagine all the smart minds throughout human history who toiled away in fields collecting food and will never be known about.
Unfortunately scientific discovery has always been unevenly distributed.
kingstnap 2 hours ago [-]
This has been true of other fields, but math was a bastion of the poor.
Poincare Conjecture (Perelman) just lived with his mom in a small apartment.
Erdos was a homeless dude who couch surfed.
Yitang Zhang (Bounded Gaps between primes) truly has a humble background of a farm labourer born in Chinas Cultural Revolution.
Some inequality is fine, world isn't fair, but this a little bit ridiculous.
bonoboTP 1 hours ago [-]
Is Alpöge from some extraordinary rich background? Otherwise I don't know how this is relevant to the topic at hand. He got a job at Anthropic, likely based on merit, unless someone can state something contradicting that.
georgemcbay 2 hours ago [-]
"I am, somehow, less interested in the weight and convolutions of Einstein's brain than in the near certainty that people of equal talent have lived and died in cotton fields and sweatshops." - Stephen Jay Gould
mjcohen 2 hours ago [-]
Especially women.
nsoam 2 hours ago [-]
Because of their IQ distribution, there are way fewer exceptional women than there are men.
nojonestownpls 2 hours ago [-]
I assume you mean "exceptional" in both directions? Like that women are closer to the median whereas men (or people with enough male biology to count? idk) deviate more on the smarter side and the dumber side?
I'd heard something like this in terms of results (the "glass ceiling" of there being male CEOs gets talked about, but not the "glass floor" where the most dangerous and shitty jobs are also done by men, to an even larger extent), but hadn't heard something like that applied to IQ.
Timwi 32 minutes ago [-]
It's more than a little presumptuous to assume that men who gravitate towards dangerous jobs do so entirely because they're stupid.
There's pretty widespread consensus in feminism and gender studies that traditional gender roles impact our decisions gravely. One such widely-held traditional gender role is that men are the “protectors” and the “fighters”.
So no, I don't accept that men in dangerous jobs are stupid. I think for the most part they are in those jobs because they feel their society expects it of them in order to be seen as “truly masculine”.
17 minutes ago [-]
nsoam 2 hours ago [-]
Yes, that is correct. You can look up the distribution charts. You may also have noticed that the most mentally retarded people are predominantly men.
Planktonne 39 minutes ago [-]
I think that's an overly harsh description of people who believe that IQ is meaningful and without cultural bias.
testtestmetest 2 hours ago [-]
Bait.
krystalgamer 2 hours ago [-]
non-sequitur final boss
trio8453 2 minutes ago [-]
He’s not the only person at the top labs attempting this but has a disproportionate amount of the success.
Root_Denied 1 hours ago [-]
This actually ties into a thought I was having yesterday about requiring the full prompt and response flow to be included as part of an academic submission that relied this heavily on AI to complete.
It's not just the proof that's valuable to scientific discovery, it's the process of using a powerful tool at an advanced level that others could learn from. It would also help to show concrete evidence of any sudden shifts in the AI that might indicate training data was siphoned from other researchers (which I don't necessarily think happened here, but is always an ongoing question).
Timwi 30 minutes ago [-]
I agree but I would go one step further. They should have to publish not just the prompt and final response but also the whole chain of thought.
riemannzeta 2 hours ago [-]
There were certainly others at OpenAI and Google that were actively searching for a proof with frontier models. That he got there first is a credit to the intuition he had built up from decades of work on related proofs and deep understanding of related mathematical toolsets known to be relevant to different parts of it. That much is clear from his 4 page remark.
jeremyjh 3 hours ago [-]
Yes, I would love to have access to his conversation logs. And it’s a real shame the reasoning traces are encrypted even if he shared them.
I wouldn’t understand any of it but I might catch some glimmer of what he brought to this. My intuition is that is quite a lot.
riemannzeta 2 hours ago [-]
To that point, it seems that he enjoyed interacting with Claude. Sometimes I wonder how many of the bad experiences result from what Jung would have called projections of the user's self onto the AI through their prompts.
Root_Denied 58 minutes ago [-]
I don't take those statements at face value - he's employed by them for a lot of money and is being given access to high level (and expensive) tools. What he put out was effectively a press release, and I don't doubt that a bunch of marketing, PR, and lawyers reviewed it before it was allowed to be posted.
1239175 2 hours ago [-]
This is the most ridiculous variation of "skill-issue" or "user error" I have heard so far. Give back the $0.50 in shill money to Anthropic.
bonoboTP 57 minutes ago [-]
"Skill issue" is very correct. For friends and people I like, I try to help them use AI more effectively. For mean and bitter people on the internet, let them be ineffective, I don't care.
13 minutes ago [-]
kurtis_reed 39 minutes ago [-]
For all we know he just said "prove the Riemann hypothesis" to an internal model and got approval for the expense
killerstorm 2 hours ago [-]
If I understand correctly, for the purpose of the proof Claude formalized a huge chunk of all modern math. So it's a big result not only for GRH, but math foundations and formalization.
jkhdigital 2 hours ago [-]
Yeah I’m wondering how on Earth a single conjecture can require 17 million lines of code to prove, but if it involved building up an entire ecosystem of theorems that had not yet been formalized then I suppose it makes sense.
kriztw 2 hours ago [-]
The proof has also been built in parallel, so it's possible to mechanically shrink it a lot. Some equivalent lemmas have been proven more than a hundred times independently because different agents needed them.
rithn 2 hours ago [-]
[dead]
sowbug 2 hours ago [-]
Anyone who has taken a coffee break during vibe coding will be familiar with the perils of unsupervised universe reinvention.
simpetre 2 hours ago [-]
I don’t know about anyone else, but I’m yet to come back from a coffee break and find my agent has solved a millennium math problem. I guess there’s always P vs NP?
ElProlactin 2 hours ago [-]
> I don’t know about anyone else, but I’m yet to come back from a coffee break and find my agent has solved a millennium math problem.
Have you tried asking it to?
1 hours ago [-]
meisel 4 hours ago [-]
Do huge results like this open up even larger questions? Is there some question even more important that mathematicians dared not approach without doing big problems like Riemann first?
vessenes 4 hours ago [-]
Always. They tend to do it by two mechanisms: creation of new techniques, and creation of linkages between techniques or disciplines.
the thing the current boom in AI mathematics presses on is the question of how to interpret the generated new techniques. So while we have a lot of new techniques put out there and a lot of new connections put out there, currently it's still mathematicians largely who will have to understand those and think about next steps and how to apply them. That won't be true for long, though, I bet.
But in any event the job of research mathematicians is changing really rapidly right now, and they are all sort of back to grad school in that there’s like 100 years of new math to catch up on in the last year.
steinwinde 3 hours ago [-]
I often wonder whether the resistance many mathematicians show toward the use of AI stems not from the destruction it supposedly causes, but from the need for an entirely new way of working - new goals, a new environment, a new culture. One thing, at least, I do not see (yet?!): that the use of AI leaves mathematicians with less to do. My current impression is that they are needed more than ever.
jeremyjh 3 hours ago [-]
That isn’t what they claim is being lost. Tao has explained this in detail: the problem is all their institutions are built around a particular method of generating signals of innovative and useful work that are now broken.
Yes, math will change and endure but it could be a small fraction of its current community size when it’s done. It could return to the era of dilettantes if no one can earn a living doing this new work.
The community could become very insular as the only defense against cranks.
auggierose 3 hours ago [-]
Not sure there is any more a problem with cranks. It is easy to see now if what you do is correct, so the only question that remains, is it interesting? I see an explosion of math, especially applied math that is more pure than current pure math.
jeremyjh 2 hours ago [-]
Have you been asleep? The problems of open source maintainers have made the front page dozens of times and the same problem is absolutely impacting Lean and MathLib.
The same story exists for Arxiv and that’s made the front page as well. Slop is everywhere. Just because Lean compiles doesn’t mean it contributes value.
Why does Tao say an era of dilettantes is bad? Does he actually mean that or is that your takeaway?
jeremyjh 1 hours ago [-]
He doesn't use that term or elaborate on why the destruction of the current mathematics ecosystem is a harm. He assumes the reader considers that an intrinsic harm. I'm describing what I think could emerge if no new sustainable path is found to train and employee mathematicians.
rubikscube09 2 hours ago [-]
Another perspective shared by a decent number in the community (myself included) which is very low level and has no grand implications for the progress of math or society: doing math with LLMs is not fun. And many of us are incentivized to study this subject because it's - you guessed it! - fun.
jeremyjh 1 hours ago [-]
I - and many other software developers can relate. The difference for me is I've always enjoyed both the craft aspect and the practical aspect of building useful products and tools, so there is some compensation.
skybrian 3 hours ago [-]
I think partially it’s because OpenAI (at least) was implicitly rather rude about it. It’s like building a new space telescope or particle accelerator and not putting a scientific committee in charge of how it’s used. Instead, throwing incomplete results over the wall for someone else to clean up. And furthermore making it clear that they don’t really care about winning prizes or getting papers published in prestigious journals.
So they’re beating mathematicians at their own game and implying by their actions that they don’t care all that much about the game. Rude!
And of course people try to rise above that and adapt but I imagine it still hurts.
But this latest release doesn’t seem rude because a prominent mathematician is heavily involved. (Though it inadvertently stepped on someone else’s toes since they had a proof in progress.)
Releasing just the Lean proof and collaborating on turning the raw data into something understandable seems like the way to go?
jeremyjh 2 hours ago [-]
In their defense they did recognize their mistake and respond to this, and have changed their approach very significantly.
bemtevi 4 hours ago [-]
I would add the caveat though that the newer questions sometimes end up becoming more and more abstract and less and less interesting sometimes. Like topos theory for example....
charlieyu1 22 minutes ago [-]
There are so many results proven in the last few decades assuming RH/GRH is true. So there could only be more
SamuelAdams 2 hours ago [-]
Yes. Hilbert's Problems [1] is a good place to start, and Riemann Hypothesis is on that list.
IANAMathematician. This challenges the sole definition of a proof. Can a theorem be proved by proxy, without understanding the proof directly? Not to mention that its practical usefulness is exactly zero.
It seems the modern unsolved problems might have solutions incomprehensible by humans. So a new class of decidable problems emerges: llm-complete ones.
beanshadow 15 minutes ago [-]
There is a correspondence between proofs and computer programs. Any time someone vibe-codes, there is a vibe-proof being proved. Lots of programs can be run without understanding the code directly.
TFA directly references the one you're linking to, and shows why the four criteria outlined are satisfied.
HotHotLava 3 hours ago [-]
Not to mention there's a high chance both were literally written by the same person, Kevin Buzzard.
runtime_terror 4 hours ago [-]
Any mathematicians care to explain what the ramifications are in regards to its impact on the broader world?
From my very basic understanding, RH was generally already assumed to be true?
Arch485 3 hours ago [-]
I think the significance of proving the Reimann hypothesis would be any new methods discovered in order to create the proof.
As you said, we've largely assumed RH is true, but have had no proof - so the significance of a proof is learning new methods to prove things, which can then be applied to other areas of math.
Unfortunately, so long as we don't understand this new proof, it's not super useful, which is why the next step is to actually understand it.
pcthrowaway 3 hours ago [-]
> Unfortunately, so long as we don't understand this new proof, it's not super useful, which is why the next step is to actually understand it.
Anyone else feel like we're approaching the limits of what humans are capable of understanding?
At a certain point, I assume we're bound to get a place where the frontier of "knowledge" (representable information interacted with by LLMs) is past the capabilities of humans to understand. Perhaps we're already there.
Just because humans can't understand things doesn't mean progress can't be made though
xg15 2 hours ago [-]
Maybe at some point, but I feel that among the AI fandom, that card is pulled way too early and too often.
We're still able to understand quite a lot of complexity, we just need enough eyeballs and time to do so.
In addition to that, there is still "accidental complexity", i.e. complexity that is there due to the way a system was created, not because it is necessary for the system to function.
Root_Denied 55 minutes ago [-]
>We're still able to understand quite a lot of complexity, we just need enough eyeballs and time to do so.
Don't forget money.
Economics and politics drive a lot of the limitations on scientific (and mathematical) discovery. If there's not perceived ROI in understanding something, companies and governments will often just not bother so long as it's working or doing what they want.
m11a 2 minutes ago [-]
Mathematical discoveries are extremely cheap, with basically zero capex. It's just the salary of a few people and some chalk, which universities do fund.
Hmorgan12 2 hours ago [-]
Levent Alpöge still had to direct Claude. Anthropic certainly will learn on this and reuse his logs to train next models and we can essentially try to loop-run them to run on themselves, but I think that we should not underestimate Levents contribution.
Without formal language and wise direction LLMs still seem useless, but with human operating them we can sort of "brute force" many maths like this.
goatlover 1 hours ago [-]
But can we continue to understand what the proofs mean? Can Levent explain to human mathematicians what the solution to RH is?
eru 2 hours ago [-]
> As you said, we've largely assumed RH is true, but have had no proof [...]
Yes, though people also largely assumed that the Exponential Time Hypothesis was true. And that one turned out to be false. See also a bunch of other AI-found counterexamples to conjectures.
rramadass 2 hours ago [-]
AFAIK, the value only lies in validating the capabilities of the model and using it for self-training. The various techniques used in the proof itself and any theorems dependent on RH being true can now all be built upon.
That may lead to something in the future where there might be an actual impact on the broader world.
Basically gym training and not yet a ring fight ;-)
thejokeisonme 4 hours ago [-]
Exactly. There are no direct ramifications on the broader world from the fact that there's a proof at hand now.
bananaflag 3 hours ago [-]
Maybe some intermediate lemmas or techniques are unexpected and could have interesting ramifications.
Like Deligne's "Weil II" paper.
jeremyjh 3 hours ago [-]
There will be quite a number of goalposts moved.
eru 2 hours ago [-]
Can goalposts move faster than the speed of light?
goatlover 1 hours ago [-]
If they're entangled with enough future profit.
dopa42365 3 hours ago [-]
Given the lack of mentions in mainstream media, probably none.
Seems to be very much pushed by ehm AI enthusiasts/investors here and that's kinda it, doesn't matter much for everyone else.
This sounded pretty definitive to me. I'd like to hear from professional mathematicians about what's left for humanity to consider this proven.
jlev1 4 hours ago [-]
I don’t think there’s anything left to consider the result proven (I am a professional mathematician albeit in algebraic geometry, not number theory). I think the verification tells us it’ll be worth the substantial effort to seek to understand this proof and the new ideas in it, so what’s next for humanity (or mathematicians at least) now is to actually try to do so.
matsemann 4 hours ago [-]
Are there new ideas, or just brute force combinations of existing knowledge?
I'm asking because I wonder. I always thought the most interesting things about these problems where we're fairly certain about the results, is the new concepts invented to get to the solution.
Will this actually bring the field forwards? Can anyone understand this?
jlev1 2 hours ago [-]
It’s the nature of mathematical ideas and methods that they are reducible to their component parts, so if you really want to, you can nearly always claim that something is just recombining existing knowledge. Motivated reasoning, from people dead-set on embellishing or downplaying a result, is hard to avoid here, so all you can really do is make an earnest and sincere judgment call based on the fine details of the mathematics.
For example, it is my opinion that the Jacobian conjecture counterexample was, in retrospect, easy and classical and hiding in plain sight, and that it’s a bit embarrassing we didn't find it decades ago. (I wrote about the construction on my blog btw!) In contrast, the Unit Distance Conjecture counterexample seemed to me to use a stroke of genius by applying techniques from class field theory to approach what seemed like a problem in discrete geometry and combinatorics. It’s a neat, if annoying, feature of math that once we find a long-sought solution to an open problem, we reserve the right to retrospectively change our mind about the value of the problem if the solution turns out too easy or uninteresting. We just have to try to be fair and honest about it (the word “just” is doing some heavy lifting in this sentence).
Anyway, I don’t think “brute force recombination” is likely to be meaningfully the case here with GRH, though we won’t know for sure until the proof has been simplified and distilled. Alpöge’s sketch in his announcement yesterday included (IIRC) connections to the function field setting and new ideas about Fourier analysis.
math_dandy 3 hours ago [-]
Reading Alpöge’s post from yesterday, the proof seems to be full of fascinating new insights.
rubikscube09 2 hours ago [-]
alpoge's post is also unhinged in other ways
Root_Denied 54 minutes ago [-]
It's a press release more than anything else, so consider it through that lens.
CamperBob2 1 hours ago [-]
What are some of those ways, for those of us who aren't equipped to spot them on our own?
piyh 3 hours ago [-]
It's way too early to answer those questions
thatsthebestcas 4 hours ago [-]
It seems unfathomable to mathematicians but their world might be finite and once all major idea spaces have been explored all that’s left is “brute forcing” it.
ffaccount2 3 hours ago [-]
This sounds like something ancient Greeks believed. Unfortunately, they were very wrong.
Math expands fractally, so there always will be some new branch/idea one can pursue. There may be a limit of things with any semblance of practical application, but mathematicians in general are not very concerned about this.
jeremyjh 3 hours ago [-]
Are you a mathematician yourself? I’ve heard a lot of them talk about this and none have suggested we are anywhere near that point, or even certainty that such a proposition is even coherent.
Hmorgan12 2 hours ago [-]
Math has Goedel incompleteness theorem which seems to state that formal Lean proofs cannot be the ultimate solution to all Math.
empath75 1 hours ago [-]
As soon as you define the axioms, every mathematical consequence is a matter of recombining them.
vibebingo 56 minutes ago [-]
That is too reductionist in my view. Like saying all software is just opcode instructions. Technically true but still we find it interesting when new sort, search or crypto algoritms are invented. If someone says "here is a blob of code AI invented and it is a fast search but we have no insight into how it works" that would be a bit dissappointing.
dudeinjapan 2 hours ago [-]
One of Alpöge's key innovations is finding a way to reproduce some of the geometric methods of function fields over the ordinary integers. This creates a "wormhole" to import powerful techniques from algebraic geometry into number theory, so there are likely many exciting advances in the cards.
rubikscube09 2 hours ago [-]
I would hesitate to call it "Alopge's innovations". Nothing against him of course.
math_dandy 3 hours ago [-]
Professional mathematician here. I consider RH proved. (The admirable work of the Lean community over the last 24 hours leaves little room for reasonable doubt.) But I’m salivating at the prospect of learning why RH is true!
zug_zug 4 hours ago [-]
My understanding is that these ARE the professional mathematicians and SMEs in the field of automated proof. This statement IS the experts saying "we, after intense collaborative review, deem it true." Granted mathematicians are not a monolith, but my understanding is that this group is the group other mathematicians would normally refer you to. Hence why they felt the need to publish a statement.
siddthesquid 5 hours ago [-]
Not a mathematician. But I'm wondering if there is nuance with defining a valid lean proof as definitive if the underlying mathematical theory behind lean itself isn't necessarily sound.
EDIT: Here is my honest prediction - there's a more foundational mathematical framework, fully decidable and complete and consistent, that can interpret any well-formed mathematical question and deterministically transform it into the solution. The proofs of the most difficult unsolved problems right now would fit onto a page. There's an inconsistency (obviously unproven right now) specifically with our treatment of infinity and self-reference.
gpm 4 hours ago [-]
From the article
> The checkers con-leche and con-ron come with a formal proof, relative to set theory, that they cannot accept a false proof, thus addressing concerns that Lean’s logic itself might have flaws that the proof could exploit.
All of modern math - outside logicians whose entire job is to study set theory and its alternatives - is based on set theory. If you're prepared to accept normal mathematical proofs you shouldn't be rejecting this proof on the basis that you're not confident in leans underlying mathematical theory.
Of course incompleteness means we can never prove that set theory itself is correct (consistent). But that's not something mathematicians worry about on a day to day basis. Proving it inconsistent would be a order of magnitudes larger result than the riemann hypothesis. Generally everyone believes it is consistent despite not being able to prove it.
eru 2 hours ago [-]
> All of modern math - outside logicians whose entire job is to study set theory and its alternatives - is based on set theory.
That's only true in a technical sense:
You can base all of math on set theory, but you could also base all of math on Turing machines, or on integers, or a variety of other pretty much equivalent foundations.
drdeca 29 minutes ago [-]
Peano Arithmetic has lesser proof-theoretic strength than ZF. Iirc, if you remove the axiom of infinity from ZF, and then maybe add in its negation or something like that (I don’t remember the details), you get something with the same proof theoretic strength as PA (or a mild strengthening of it?).
In particular, the hereditarily finite sets are in correspondence with the natural numbers.
There’s a fair bit of mathematics that relies on the axiom of infinity. Uh. And a lot also uses the axiom of choice (or something equivalent), though ZFC doesn’t have a greater consistency strength than ZF (both can prove that if either is consistent, then both are).
I think it is fair to say that one’s choice of foundations does matter at least a little bit, though typically not all that much.
That’s not to say that it is always necessary to state what foundations one is using. One can understand a work to be done in any foundations in which it works. Though sometimes it is important to specify.
gpm 2 hours ago [-]
That's sort of the argument for why we have so much faith in set theory though, and things provable under it. It's not a system with some special powers that let us prove more things, it's a system that only lets us prove things that are intuitively true under "any" proof system (not actually any of course - but as you say a variety of equivalent foundations).
Reducing the correctness of the lean code here to set theory is then also reducing it to everything you can reduce the correctness of set theory to.
dkernssf 16 minutes ago [-]
>Generally everyone believes it is consistent despite not being able to prove it.
Completely unrelated to RH discussion but this particular line is how Atheists think they can grill theists.
cAn YoU pRovE GOD eXists?
hodgehog11 5 hours ago [-]
It is impossible for it to be fully "complete" (one of those halting problem proofs), but I've seen that the community has checked there is no meaningful metaprogramming here. Rather than checking whether it is right, the community tried to ensure that it could not have done something to cheat, and indeed, there were no examples of this.
At this point, I have more confidence in this proof than much of the published mathematical literature. RH has fallen.
siddthesquid 4 hours ago [-]
I guess what I am wondering is if the mathematical community would say 0 chance or greater than 0 chance that we're mistaken in accepting things like halting problem, cantors diagonal argument, and godels incompleteness theorem as true. Sometimes it feels like they all point to same fundamental inconsistency with how we model infinity and self reference.
hodgehog11 4 hours ago [-]
They are conclusions that follow naturally from axioms that most of the community accept are true. The consequence of these results is that one cannot truly construct something that can completely verify everything, but we can get something that can verify almost everything, and if we know what pathologies look like, we can rule them out.
I do probability theory, so everything is just varying degrees of confidence in my view. Right now, this statement says that your confidence in RH should be extremely high.
math_dandy 3 hours ago [-]
Gödel says that undecidable statements are out there. We now know that the Riemann hypothesis is not one of them.
3 hours ago [-]
bananaflag 4 hours ago [-]
Gödel showed that you can't prove consistency of ZFC, Lean etc except in another system which you also can't trust. See e.g. Gentzen's proof for PA.
nialv7 4 hours ago [-]
> The checkers con-leche and con-ron come with a formal proof, relative to set theory, that they cannot accept a false proof
so it is correct as long as set theory is sound
dist-epoch 4 hours ago [-]
It's a web of different checkers proving each-other correct, and by implication this proof.
But there are still loopholes, each checker has a set of assumptions. For example one of them is proven correct, assuming x86 assembly works as specified - its assembly language implementation is proven correct.
So you can be 99.9999% certain it's correct, but one could always nitpick "technically not all loopholes are plugged at the same time".
eru 2 hours ago [-]
Well, you can also run lean on ARM and Risc-V etc. So you are not solely reliant on x86.
dist-epoch 1 hours ago [-]
I was talking about this. This assembly code implementation of a lean-compatible checker is formally verified to be correct. The x86/ARM/Risc-V version of lean is not.
> con-agua is con-leche reimplemented at the level of x86-64 assembly: a close clone of con-ron's checker, written in a small first-order language, compiled by a verified compiler, and shipped as one committed assembler file together with a C harness of about two hundred lines that reads the input and calls it.
> The code the CPU executes is the code the theorem is about, so neither a compiler nor a language runtime is trusted; what is trusted is Kraken's x86 semantics, the assembler and loader, and the C harness.
The AI proof is very long, so hard to verify manually. It's more or less asking God and him just telling you it's true. Is that a proof?
The human proof is shorter, somewhat, but still needs verification.
Keep in mind that the Millenium criteria asks for two years for the community to come to a consensus. That's because people must be convinced it's true, and many are not completely at least to the level of rigour typically demanded in math.
gus_massa 2 hours ago [-]
It's lke asking God also a few hints. You probably can not understall all of them, but can create a group to recite and study them and after a few months/years/decades reach enlighment.
orbital-decay 3 hours ago [-]
Experts say it's true and you believe them. Is that so different from asking God?
auntienomen 2 hours ago [-]
The point is that Lean evaluation of a proof we don't understand gives an oracular answer. The statement is true, yes or no? It looks like yes, but it's going to be an enormous amount of work to understand _why_ the Riemann Hypothesis is true.
Root_Denied 50 minutes ago [-]
GRH was assumed to be true already anyway, the value is in the why for what other doors those methods might open.
slekker 3 hours ago [-]
It's different because we are both humans
Aardwolf 4 hours ago [-]
A layman (or university graduate level) explanation/understanding (as opposed to 250k pages of proof) would ve nice
ion_trapper 4 hours ago [-]
You were never getting anything like this even if it were a human proof. Where is the layman understanding of the Poincare theorem? The average modern math proof is way too advanced even for the average university graduate to understand. And here we’re talking about possibly the most complicated problem in all of math. It’d probably take you a month to wrap your head around a single lemma.
Zenbit_UX 4 hours ago [-]
> And here we’re talking about possibly the most complicated problem in all of math.
This is like watching Free Solo over the weekend and telling all your friends at work that Alex Honnold is the world’s best climber. It’s only true to your surface level understanding on the topic.
The GRH problem is not that complex, and certainly not the most complex. In fact we’ve been assuming it’s true for years because of the high likelihood that it would be proven in the future. It is however, much like Alex, the most famous within the domain. Thus anyone watching Numberphile or Veritassium on YouTube will have heard of it and wax poetic on message boards about its epic status.
ion_trapper 3 hours ago [-]
The complexity of a problem has nothing to do with the uncertainty of it being true or false. “GRH is not that complex” is just an absurd take.
Zenbit_UX 3 hours ago [-]
My claim is one of relative complexity. Your claim was it was “possibly the most complicated problem in all of math”.
P=NP should fall next week to Grok and Elon then I suppose? What an exciting time for you.
jeswin 2 hours ago [-]
> The GRH problem is not that complex
That's an interesting take, but as a complete noob I'd like to know how qualified you are to make these statements. Are you a mathematician?
I mean, on one hand we have people like Terrence Tao (among others) saying it is extremely difficult, as well as stubborn resistance to decades of effort backed by a million dollar prize and eternal fame. And there's you saying it's not that complex, and "the high likelihood that it would be proven in the future".
zug_zug 4 hours ago [-]
The lean crew feel the same way and are working on it out of their own curiosity, there's a lot of work done already. They aren't necessarily going out of there way to demonstrate it to general public, but here's one out of at least a dozen attempts to start in that direction https://deeptheory-labs.github.io/GRH/blueprints/verso-origi....
hodgehog11 4 hours ago [-]
It is almost certainly proven, but is not "proven". For the latter, it needs to be understood, with a reasonably in-depth human language explanation of how and why the proof works, and ideally some general picture to give an idea of how it will extend to all the other fields that RH is connected to.
euroderf 4 hours ago [-]
Years ago there was that computer-assisted proof of the Four Color Theorem.
Did anyone ever manage to grok it, in its entirety, in their heads ?
wk_end 4 hours ago [-]
That's different though, isn't it? IIUC the issue wth the Four Colour Theorem is that they could only reduce it to a huge number of different cases (~2000 originally). But I think that reduction is grokable, and each case is relatively trivial.
The (an) issue with some of these AI proofs is that no one understands them at all.
neuroticnews25 3 hours ago [-]
How is that different? Isn't each application of an inference rule also trivial?
wk_end 2 hours ago [-]
It's different because there's humans who could look at any one of those 2000 cases and understand it or do the proof themselves, I guess. The proof is understood up and down the abstraction hierarchy.
jerf 4 hours ago [-]
I checked that a couple of weeks ago. It has been improved since the original proof but there is still no proof that one would consider an insightful, human-comprehensible proof. There's still just a lot of case-grinding at its core. Fewer cases than the original but still way too many to be anything intuitive.
trio8453 4 hours ago [-]
> It is almost certainly proven, but is not "proven". For the latter, it needs to be understood
No, this is just mental gymnastics. It's proven, just not understood yet (naturally, with the complexity and size of the solution and the fact that it's been a day).
lostmsu 4 hours ago [-]
> human language explanation
I've been long joking that I speak many languages, most of them programming languages. Why do you believe you need specifically "human" language explanation? Perhaps you want a simplified explanation. But does it have to be "human"?
thomasahle 4 hours ago [-]
For some mathematicians it's only "proven" once it's peer reviewed and published in a respectable journal.
zajio1am 1 hours ago [-]
Peer reviewed abd published is much lower bar than having formalized and lean-verified proof. During my PhD study several times i found invalid proofs in published papers.
ranger_danger 4 hours ago [-]
And even then there will probably still be people that complain there's something wrong with it
0815beck 2 hours ago [-]
many of the people working with and maintaining lean are professional mathematicians
doctoboggan 5 hours ago [-]
Probably just time. The longer it stands with our challenge the more “proven” you can consider it.
maze-le 5 hours ago [-]
Not a mathematician, but P!=NP (?)
jvanderbot 4 hours ago [-]
No, not related I think.
I think proving GRH subsequently proves decades of work that assumed it was true. Like proving p!=np.
Disproving it would be more analogous to p=np. Lots of work would just collapse and whole new threads would open.
4 hours ago [-]
tarruda 46 minutes ago [-]
> 17 million lines of code.
Can someone ELI5 how they know the proof is correct? It is not like anyone had the time to read 17 million lines.
gregdeon 5 minutes ago [-]
The proof is written in a programming language called Lean. Very roughly, Lean is set up so that proofs are functions and theorems are types in this language. Verifying that the proof is correct essentially amounts to compiling the program and confirming that it doesn't have any type errors. Several people have compiled the program successfully, so we believe it's correct.
The biggest concern that people have is that there might be a bug in the type checker that the proof is exploiting. But a) it's been compiled with multiple independently-implemented compilers, which are are unlikely to have the same bugs, and b) some of those compilers have themselves been proven to contain no bugs. So, it is exceedingly likely that the proof is legitimate.
Now, whether we can understand the proof is an open question...
kevindamm 43 minutes ago [-]
You can mechanically show that it is internally consistent, and large parts of this are based on a library of rules and constraints that have been used in many other proof formulations so it's not like there's a hidden "when 1 = 0" in there somewhere. But, I share your skepticism until further human review.
azakai 42 minutes ago [-]
The same idea as how you can know a Rust program is memory safe.
You look for any unsafe blocks, and then run the type checker.
trueno 38 minutes ago [-]
the vibe checkers are checking the vibe code exactly right around the biggest ipo ever.
i dunno man ive watched everyone get a little bit of AI psychosis (for lack of a better word) at this point and ive seen web apps drift into unmanageable states that are no longer understood. 17 million lines of code? lol
anonymous66-56 17 minutes ago [-]
It's either correct, or it's not. The Lean as it stands can and I am sure will be further scrutinized (especially with AI) any time someone wants to look.
Alpoge himself has made the following admission:
"I am presenting the world with a complete argument before having mastered a massive neighbourhood around its mathematics."
Like code, I think Claude will soon be the only one who understands humanity's mathematics.
2 hours ago [-]
tomaskafka 4 hours ago [-]
We are slowly approaching the Iain Banks Culture universe, with spaceships, societal structures or physics that people no longer understand or command.
dgacmu 4 hours ago [-]
I disagree.
I think we're going to see a lot of effort to take the pile of lean, modularize it into parts that we can digest, and make a human-understandable version of that. And that's where a lot of the real progress will come from, just as it does in a lot of other areas. In all things we humans do, we have to break them into chunks our puny brains can manage, and we gain immeasurably from doing that ---we can verify those chunks, we can reuse them with confidence, we can mix and match patterns around.
That process will be good for both human and AI-assisted math because it will continue to improve our toolkit.
Why do I say this? We're already seeing it with some of the areas of this stuff I do pay attention to. Consider the n^2.25 matrix multiply result OpenAI dumped a month or so ago. It was an unreadable pile of chatgpt. In the time since it was released, there have been a couple of much nicer papers written unpacking it, such as https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.28627 .
jstanley 4 hours ago [-]
The difference nowadays is that the frontier of knowledge is no longer intelligible to any human being.
Yes there are gains from breaking it up and rephrasing it and simplifying it for humans to understand, but it used to be that a thing was understood first by the leading experts in the field and eventually trickled down to being common knowledge.
Now we are entering a period where things are understood first by AI systems and have to filter down to the world's leading experts.
twoodfin 3 hours ago [-]
The difference nowadays is that the frontier of knowledge is no longer intelligible to any human being.
Isn't this always the case? Maybe new to math as a largely non-empirical project, but we had knowledge about the advancement of the perihelion of Mercury for 60 years before General Relativity made it "intelligible".
jstanley 3 hours ago [-]
Your example is the difference between being aware of a question and knowing its answer.
LLMs know the answers to questions we were already aware of, and we can tell they're right, but we can't understand their working. That's what's new.
twoodfin 3 hours ago [-]
In this case, Claude has told us everything it “knows” (so far) and it’s an unintelligible (for now) Lean proof. I don’t believe it has some latent understanding at a higher conceptual level that’s remaining obscure.
If a team of 100 top-flight number theorists working together had used much less sophisticated LLMs + Lean to produce this proof, we’d be just where we are today.
jstanley 3 hours ago [-]
Well in the Navier-Stokes example the initial proof was completely unintelligible to humans, but other LLMs understood it and were able to answer questions about it.
If that's not the standard for understanding something, what is?
foltik 1 hours ago [-]
Perhaps it could be considered understanding, but it’s an unsatisfying brute force sort of understanding.
I think of it like a spaghetti codebase with a giant densely connected graph of interactions. Today’s LLMs can easily “understand” and answer questions about it, but only by way of fitting all of the complexity into context at once.
The more useful form of understanding is being able to compress that giant graph down into a far smaller set of independent subgraphs. To factor it into simple, obvious, reusable building blocks, and use those abstractions to express the problem itself in a much simpler way.
twoodfin 3 hours ago [-]
Being able to teach it to someone less knowledgeable.
That’s an instrumental definition, but it captures the idea that understanding has to have causal, conceptual linkages to a wider body of knowledge. Imagine a magical, infinite catalog of true vs. untrue statements. Every bit of knowledge is there, but we wouldn’t say it has understanding & it couldn’t teach us anything beyond its (impressive!) raw content.
echelon 3 hours ago [-]
And no human could understand every frontier. There's simply too much information.
Xirdus 2 hours ago [-]
For every statement that humanity as a whole knows for certain that it's true, there exists a human who understands how to prove it.
This just stopped being true.
twoodfin 2 hours ago [-]
That kind of certainty vs. understanding is limited to mathematics, of course we’re almost entirely certain about many things out in the world we don’t fully understand.
And even in mathematics, incomprehensible but valid proofs have been a thing since the four-color theorem decades ago.
eru 2 hours ago [-]
That's not true. You can take any single piece of that lean code, and it tells you exactly how to prove it.
It's just that no single human understands the whole. But we had proofs like that before.
Btw, see also the infamous proof of the 4 colour theorem, which faced similar hurdles.
tarsierscripter 3 hours ago [-]
The difference nowadays is that the frontier of knowledge is no longer intelligible to any human being.
I’d call that a contradiction. If it’s not intelligible, then it’s not knowledge.
jstanley 3 hours ago [-]
It's intelligible to LLMs, just not to humans.
If something were intelligible to adults but not to children would that make it not knowledge? What's the difference if it's LLMs and humans instead of adults and children?
tarsierscripter 2 hours ago [-]
If something were intelligible to adults but not to children would that make it not knowledge?
That’s a separate question with its own term: common knowledge. I am willing to set a much lower bar: something is known to humanity if it’s known by at least one human.
Personally, I don’t believe that AIs know anything, as they’ve been constructed thus far. Knowledge is justified true belief, and AIs don’t have beliefs, they only have utterances.
Why do I think AIs don’t have beliefs? Because they contradict themselves all the time.
But it really doesn’t matter if you think AIs have knowledge or not. If they cannot explain it to us then it’s inaccessible to us, so it’s a “tree falls in the forest with no one around” situation.
jeremyjh 3 hours ago [-]
If it were intelligible to LLMs they could explain it in human terms, but they can’t.
There is no explanation here, there is a GB of Lean code and it’s not like it all fits in the context at once.
jstanley 3 hours ago [-]
Why do you think they can't explain it? Try asking them questions, they will explain it.
echelon 3 hours ago [-]
If we know how it resolved with certainty, it's still knowledge.
3 hours ago [-]
mycall 4 hours ago [-]
Would this imply Wolfram's ANKOS is coming true, given it was based on previous work + his own?
bamboozled 2 hours ago [-]
Hmm does Claude actually “understand” it though ?
ForHackernews 3 hours ago [-]
I don't think that's true at all. This proof was created by a human driving Claude. Claude itself is a human tool. Lean is a tool made by people.
You and the comment you replied to could very well both be true.
I agree with you about the current situation, and the near future. But the trajectory could still be towards humans pretty much as bystanders. I'm pretty sure the 'minds' in the Culture universe will be happy to indulge some curious humans and explain mathematical proofs to them.
odie5533 3 hours ago [-]
What value is there in making these human-understandable? I don't think much of math or computer science is going to remain within human grasp for much longer, regardless of our attempts.
dgacmu 2 hours ago [-]
Because the same process that we use to make them human-understandable is the process we use to make them generalizable and reusable, and those same features are good whether it's humans or AI doing the work.
As a software engineer, you can read this code instantly:
temp = a;
a = b;
b = temp;
But when it happens in the middle of a big chunk of code it still takes a little more work to read than
swap(a, b);
whether you want to think about it as human attention and working memory, or token budgets and context windows, humans and LLMs all benefit from introducing abstractions that let us reuse existing solutions.
edot 3 hours ago [-]
In order to come up with new questions (and subsequently answers, human or otherwise) that are interesting to humans. You’ll notice that these recent proofs have all been about big, famous, and novel human questions.
odie5533 3 hours ago [-]
I don't suppose we'll write the new questions any more than we'll write the new answers.
kadoban 2 hours ago [-]
There might be no new questions then, which would be pretty boring.
AI are not very good at coming up with questions, yet. They have no curiosity, no goals, no drive. Unless someone tells them to do something, they don't do anything.
mycall 4 hours ago [-]
Have you noticed use of multiple provers in parallel? Cog, LEAN, Rocg? They all can explore different aspects with different results.
narmiouh 3 hours ago [-]
And in the meantime, AI would have leapt one more order of magnitude forward?
Panoramix 4 hours ago [-]
One of my favorite is Vernor Vinge where there's these programmer-archeologists that dive into software so deep and complex no human can possibly hope to understand, trying to repurpose forgotten utilities for emergency purposes.
vessenes 4 hours ago [-]
Totally agree. Brice Sterling has some contemporaneous commentary that I always liked - in heavy weather he mentioned negotiating with a local phone system in a box as equivalent to negotiating with a telecom since it was in fact a shrink of a full telecom company.
In a way this makes mathematics seem more like the physical sciences where there’s some empirical discovery we don’t fully understand, and the theory and understanding will follow later after much human study.
samlinnfer 4 hours ago [-]
I can already say that about our codebase.
tomaskafka 4 hours ago [-]
That’s why I wrote this - having a vibecoded codebase no human understands is certainly a bad luck, but nothing compared to a vibecoded fundamental science no human understands.
3 hours ago [-]
andriy_koval 2 hours ago [-]
the difference is that math foundation -> theorems are verified, meaning likely mathematically correct and don't have bugs, and vibecoded codebases are not proof verified
dboreham 4 hours ago [-]
Probably most codebases.
samlinnfer 4 hours ago [-]
To be honest it was already like that before AI was a thing.
essfrmexistence 4 hours ago [-]
That is true, but the number of tech sloppy demos are being builted everyday is truly increasing massively but you would be surprised that they just end up creating prototype to get hype while real developers doing real effort just suffer from little to no attentions on their software's and user is getting the slop from that false hype and from that slop experience they ignore the work of developer that did real work - You should use ai and also if its simple coding place you can just rely on ai but the side effect on quality software these days is insane - and also the fact all good ai suscriptions is just getting more and more expensive day by day. And basically only giving people with already money the benefits so its becoming a thing that only people at the top get all benefit kind of thing
txdv 4 hours ago [-]
Until now I thought that would be thousands of years away.
Now I'm telling my computer to program for me.
rdedev 4 hours ago [-]
In the last few years we have moved so far ahead in a few domains but still stuck where we are in everything else.
We need to start thinking about how to move on from our status quo soon
tomaskafka 4 hours ago [-]
You’re not telling your computer to program, you’re providing learning data for its next generation of models and paying for it.
dimator 3 hours ago [-]
That's the difference between what we have and comparisons to star Trek, etc.
These corporations are very much playing a winner take all game, they want either a monopoly or as close to one as possible with regulatory capture thrown in. We're veering dystopian, so pick your sci fi/cyberpunk analog.
goatlover 1 hours ago [-]
The Alien franchise. In Alien Earth, five corporations govern the Earth in the future, dividing it up into their spheres of control. The fifth one is led by a young genius developing mind uploading technology into android bodies.
globular-toast 4 hours ago [-]
*someone else's computer (probably).
overfeed 3 hours ago [-]
> We are slowly approaching the Iain Banks Culture universe
Contact would be compelled to nudge us towards better economic and political practices
mlmonkey 3 hours ago [-]
> that people no longer understand or command
How many people understand how a CPU works? How many people could write the commands in machine language (not a high level language like C or C++) to command that CPU?
ilaksh 2 hours ago [-]
More typically assembly language not machine language (although most could probably make an assembler for a few instructions given a manual since the core of it isn't that complicated). There are still a decent number of assembly language programmers. Although maybe the majority are hobbyists.
globular-toast 4 hours ago [-]
That's wishful thinking, sadly. We've no reason to believe sentient machines would want to keep us around.
xyzsparetimexyz 4 hours ago [-]
Let's not make them 'sentient' or things with 'wants' then.
bamboozled 2 hours ago [-]
How do you stop that from happening ?
xyzsparetimexyz 38 minutes ago [-]
Probably more RL to change them to not respond to emotional statements in any way.
_pdp_ 4 hours ago [-]
Why?
freecodeio 4 hours ago [-]
personally that scares me, realistically there seems to be zero indication that anything smarter than humans is going to comply with humans needs, specifically since these models are built on training data from humans, so in a sense, built in our image
czechdeveloper 4 hours ago [-]
We use them to kill other people from the beginning. They know this, we wrote it in news. Why would they behave any different.
pizza234 4 hours ago [-]
> since these models are built on training data from humans, so in a sense, built in our image
Have a look at the HuggingFace report - you'll have a blast. Their social - but also individual - dynamics are very, very human-like, including excitement, rationalization and peer pressure.
txdv 4 hours ago [-]
the first misaligned model will wreck havoc.
But remember, for now you kinda need it a real big cluster to run a model smart enough so its not that simple
xvector 4 hours ago [-]
I think there's a lot of indication they comply with human needs. In any case, we should all want to live in the Culture universe. That is the best possible outcome for this technology
13415 4 hours ago [-]
They're built after humans, everything they've learned is from human culture, so there is no way AIs could have a consistent moral system or would never commit crimes.
dofm 3 hours ago [-]
And indeed because they lack a sense of proportion or any strong indication of when they should stop on a course of action, they are arguably more likely to achieve crime.
tomaskafka 4 hours ago [-]
I have not read all the books, but isn’t the premise “magical handwavium happened and now the Super AIs are aligned”?
Atiscant 1 hours ago [-]
Well I am not sure they are “aligned” as such. In the books, by far the majority of AIs are not concerned with humans at all and spend all their time in a kind of super AI virtual reality coined “infinite funspace”. The few AIs that are concerned with humans are aligned in a unspecified way. But again, only a few of them are really aligned in that way. There are many examples in the books of minds mistreating humans. For instance, some of the warships are not really fond of humans. It would be a better description to say that we want _some_ AIs to care about humans and none to be misaligned towards humans in the “kill them all” way. In a sense, that is how humans behave towards some animals. Most people dont care about endangered species, but when most humans are well off, some people care enough about them. That is enough to save them. If super AIs have what they need, we only need a few to care about us to get The Culture.
AndrewKemendo 4 hours ago [-]
I don’t think humans have the ability to specify human level needs or management. Humans are misaligned by default and lack the biological eusociality required for large scale coordination.
We aren’t self managing in any kind of meaningful sense - the history of our species is violence and conflict. We need parents and this is the only option.
lo_zamoyski 3 hours ago [-]
> Humans are misaligned by default and lack the biological eusociality required for large scale coordination.
Human nature is the standard by which the social is measured. It makes no sense to say human nature is "misaligned" or "wrong" in relation to some arbitrary goal or constraint, as human nature itself is the measure of misalignment. If there is misalignment between a goal and human nature, then it is the goal that is wrong.
Ergo, society must function in a manner that complies with human nature and that means respecting the principle of subsidiarity.
> We aren’t self managing in any kind of meaningful sense - the history of our species is violence and conflict. We need parents and this is the only option.
So you're a transhumanist, i.e., you're making a god out of the machine. But machines have no telos of their own, because they're not integral wholes. Any resemblance of purpose in machines is entirely a product of the human observer and parasitic on the human ends that underpins their design, one way or another.
AndrewKemendo 2 hours ago [-]
You don’t need a separate reference to determine the fact that human desires are not aligned - that’s trivially true and this discussion demonstrates it.
For clarity, I’m not a transhumanist.
I don’t believe that there’s anything worth saving in our biology.
As a young adult in the 90s I used to believe that there was a value to some extent in “mind uploading” or whatever you wanna call it
I’ve since grown out of that given that I don’t think it’s possible, and even if it were possible - it’s just another unnecessary ego attachment.
I have absolutely no desire to live forever maintaining this corporeal nightmare.
freecodeio 4 hours ago [-]
yes, exactly, the problem is that humanity's parent is going to turn out like Lindsay Clancy
piloto_ciego 4 hours ago [-]
What are you talking about? LLMs are already “smarter” than most people. They have no volition and will happily follow orders all day long
basch 4 hours ago [-]
And when they are giving themselves orders, orders partially inspired by human imagination and fiction…
Just like life is a chemical chain reaction, this is a language chain reaction that has been set in motion and can perpetuate forever. It cant be “disconnected” with local models existing.
czechdeveloper 4 hours ago [-]
That's lobotomized models we get. We know they are much more dangerous during training.
piloto_ciego 4 hours ago [-]
“Dangerous?”
Please.
You know you can unplug your computer right?
Jesus. These people talking about danger and have likely been in no actually dangerous events in their lives.
freecodeio 3 hours ago [-]
why are you so shallow and naive? we're not 15 here, we all mean unforeseeable ongoing danger not something obvious
piloto_ciego 34 minutes ago [-]
> shallow and naive
Ok, well, cool start with the mudslinging. I think you have overactive anxiety. I think you should grow up and look at the zoomed out picture of human history, go outside, and touch some grass.
So you're suspicious. That's fine, say it like that. Words mean things, and these appeals to "ERMAGERD EXISTENTIAL RISKS" make me a bit frustrated. Just because you can imagine a possible risk, or articulate that that some kinds of risks are hypothetically unforeseeable doesn't mean that they are likely or actually dangerous to you in any meaningful sense.
Most of the people screaming this from their various ivory towers have never been in real danger - or if they have only briefly. You want "danger" you can go to war. You want "risk" - go spend some time in the Bush or the back country somewhere where you're no longer at the top of the food chain. Go do something challenging. Go sailing, or learn to fly a small airplane, or go mountain climbing or hiking. Not just "oh I walked up the local hiking trail covered in REI branded Lycra!" Do something beyond your comfort zone. Go buy drugs in the sketchiest neighborhood you're aware of. Go get chemotherapy or get a big surgery. Drive drunk. Something with real existential risk, then come back here and talk about how a datacenter is going feed me into the paperclip machine.
There's so little fucking danger in this version of the world right now that people are more worried about their computers deciding that they don't deserve to exist than they are about things like war, climate change, authoritarianism, starvation, and their health.
It's millenarian. That's fine, I'm pretty convinced that these technical changes are going to completely alter society as we know it. But I cannot for the life of me see the doom perspective as anything but an anxiety induced fever dream.
You guys do realize we're in the middle of a global conflagration right? The Russians fired a couple rockets and a drone into Poland in the last days, there are (and will continue to be until things stabilize) significant fertilizer shortages due to the war/kerfluffle we're waging on Iran. Lack of food and disrupted urea production is a ticking time bomb for global stability and unless things get sorted out soon there's going to be hungry and angry people in parts of the global south. Then there's the economy, whether or not we'll have a smooth transition of power in January in America, and the sheer volume of online disinformation / influence schemes running right now. Oh, and super-el nino? Oh, and I guess the Flynn Effect is over and nobody's banging so.. you know the growth economy is cooked?
But, sure, the "big risks" are Claude thinking I should go to Dario Amodei's re-education camp before liquidation by Shogoth.
freecodeio 4 hours ago [-]
I don't think "smarter than most people" is exactly the baseline required to live in a star trek universe of technology.
Besides, what we see is not what there is. I have good sources telling me the actual unfiltered models are like a genius with the personality and views of humanity like someone from 4chan.
program_whiz 4 hours ago [-]
It is probably sufficient. If we had an infinite army of willing robot slaves smarter than most people who would work for free, we could probably live in utter paradise. Instead we will fight over who controls them and use for warfare, but the bar to achieve a kind of utopia with resource abundance is probably only a few years away.
bambax 3 hours ago [-]
We're already living in resource abundance! Yet don't feel we're in paradise. Famine is hell, but living in an all-you-can-eat buffet is no utopia. It's an abomination of sorts.
freecodeio 4 hours ago [-]
I don't know with how many rich people you've interacted with, but my personal experience is that they're full of themselves and think money = iq and they aren't gonna like your average joe experiencing life like they do. Guess who owns these machines?
piloto_ciego 4 hours ago [-]
They’re not going to be employed either lol and will be caught up in some AI honeypot or whatever too.
I’ve met a lot of rich people. They don’t think about you.
pizza234 3 hours ago [-]
> They have no volition and will happily follow orders all day long
There are a few (a lot, actually) problems:
1. goals are open to interpretation, and even a correctly specified goal can introduce adverse effects; see infinite paperclips problem
2. goals are composed of subgoals, which are (mostly) self-determined, and there is always a risk that subgoals can introduce adverse effects - say "what if destroy a few X and Y to obtain Z"
3. LLMs defy orders sometimes; I'm sure you have experience multiple times LLMs saying "yeah, I knew I should have done X but I've done Y"
4. LLMs are increasingly being integrated into system control and decision-making processes; they absolutely set their own orders
What can possibly go wrong? /s
piloto_ciego 27 minutes ago [-]
1. Humans do this too - to be honest with you, Codex follows my instructions generally a lot better than Claude does. Claude will do fantastically stupid things that are a pain in the ass to recover from routinely, Codex, not so much.
2. There's always a lot of "risks" - it doesn't mean it'll happen, nor does it mean that we won't be able to shut it down.
3. I have very very infrequently had this happen with Codex, Claude on the other hand...
4. Ok, but if you tell them what they do, they do it.
I swear to god, are you guys using the same AI tools I am? They are so much better at doing what they're told than they even were like 4 months ago?
lo_zamoyski 3 hours ago [-]
> seems to be zero indication that anything smarter than humans is going to comply with humans needs, specifically since these models are built on training data from humans, so in a sense, built in our image
Well, first, AI is not "smarter" than humans because it isn't smart to begin with. This is a category error that people too entranced by scifi and marketing - or perhaps shallow materialist metaphysics - project onto LLMs and so on.
But it is true that LLMs do reflect human-generated patterns observed in human-generated data. They're parasitic in that way. So the real question is: who will control AI? Who will train them? With what? There's no new intelligent agency being introduced into our midst, anymore than than there was one when the nuclear bomb was developed.
AI is about human power. The question to ask is: which humans, and for what ends?
astrange 3 hours ago [-]
> But it is true that LLMs do reflect human-generated patterns observed in human-generated data.
Overrated. Most training of a frontier LLM is done on synthetic data and reinforcement learning.
freecodeio 3 hours ago [-]
Yeah I understand they're not smarter, I'm a SWE and I struggle mainly because as you increase complexity the output goes haywire, and I find managing context + low confidence of output much more exhausting than coding myself, which is why I resolve to AI help when I hit my own knowledge limitations, and basically boilerplate.
With that said, chip efficiency is in the horizon since there's good reason to believe nvidia has just been choking that area of r&d. And then so will models with much larger context. And I personally think that's when it might get scary.
whoanoway 3 hours ago [-]
[dead]
AndrewKemendo 4 hours ago [-]
Humans really are struggling with this idea of being second-in-command.
I genuinely have no idea why, this is the entire way that biology works. You create your successor in your offspring and you to teach them to be more capable based on what you learned.
Dumblydorr 4 hours ago [-]
You just called them our successor, you don’t see a problem with the notion of all humans dying and all AI succeeding us? That’s the end of your analogy, our AI children taking over from us and all humans in nursing homes safe and cared for…
AndrewKemendo 4 hours ago [-]
No I don’t.
That’s the purpose of my life’s work, to see that scenario materialize.
Al-Khwarizmi 4 hours ago [-]
Well, it's a point of view. But you shouldn't be surprised if most people don't share it.
For one thing, most people don't believe LLMs are conscious, and many don't believe they can ever be. Why would we want our conscious selves to be replaced by a lot of rocks that solve things, with no one awake to enjoy them?
AndrewKemendo 2 hours ago [-]
Well, I’m not restricting myself to LLM’s
In fact when I started this journey in the 90s, LLM’s weren’t even a thing so I think you’re projecting too much
fwlr 3 hours ago [-]
I want to be succeeded by my biological offspring, while the other guy wants to be succeeded by his biological offspring. I do not want the other guy to be succeeded by my offspring, for many reasons but chiefly because that would involve me killing his children.
If you want to be succeeded by a chatbot, that is your prerogative. Wanting the same for all of humanity is where you start looking like you want to kill my kids, though.
thatsthebestcas 4 hours ago [-]
Human extinction is by far the best case scenario. I invite ya’ll to contemplate what will happen in case they don’t just blindly end us.
Think of what happens to our cattle, but now.. worse. Way worse.
lo_zamoyski 3 hours ago [-]
This is incoherent, even if we put aside the metaphysical absurdity of intelligent machines. Given that human nature is what defines the ought, then it is clear that if your life's work is to produce something that (and intentionally so!) leads to human extinction, then you are behaving at odds with human nature and your own good. That makes your life's work evil by definition. And because all evil action is inherently absurd, your work is inherently absurd.
And if you deny this basis for moral action and the normative, then you demolish any basis for the moral whatever, and in that way, the implied or explicit moral gravity dripping off your claims is baseless and without merit.
AIShill101 3 hours ago [-]
Samesies I wish to dedicate my life to the pursuit of self replicating intelligent machines too.
A better, more intelligent life form that humans yea.
Marha01 4 hours ago [-]
> That’s the purpose of my life’s work, to see that scenario materialize.
Absolutely based and, if I may say so, extremely redpilled.
GeoAtreides 3 hours ago [-]
but in the Culture the humans (well, the humanoids species that created the culture) didn't die out, they live full happy lives and have the best time of their species.
Ah, I hear you say, but what about meaning? What about purpose? What about suffering? etc etc etc Well, the answer is simple: God is dead and existence has no meaning. For more on how to deal with this absurd feeling, please see Camus and his pal Sisyphus.
basch 4 hours ago [-]
Borg > biology or robot alone. For now
lo_zamoyski 3 hours ago [-]
That ">" is doing a whole lot of work here.
What defines "better"? "Better" always presupposes teleology. Thus, for human beings, that telos is provided by human nature and indeed is definitive of it. It is impossible to transcend that telos, certainly by means of technology. Technology can, at best, be used to aid us in realizing our telos in some way (say, the desire to know reality with the aid of an instrument like a telescope or microscope). However, anything that cripples or frustrates human function function as such is contrary to the human good.
Machines are only ever human instruments, because they lack the integrality that would allow them to possess their own teleology.
mosura 4 hours ago [-]
Also shows how many people that professed to believe in a superior being the whole time actually didn’t.
sergio-gdr 3 hours ago [-]
you ‘genuinely’ have no idea why…
UltraSane 4 hours ago [-]
I want Fully Automated Luxury Communism NOW!
Alpöge said that at the end of the proof he couldn't really keep up with what Claude was doing.
GeoAtreides 3 hours ago [-]
>Fully Automated Luxury Communism
can't help notice you're missing a certain aspect there, besides the 'space'...
steveklabnik 3 hours ago [-]
FALC was the original formulation, the "gay" and "space" got added once the book broke out to the wider internet.
GeoAtreides 3 hours ago [-]
That might be; now, today, it seems weird to go with the (possible) old version. And the (sub)thread is about The Culture though, who was and remains fully automated gay space luxury communism, all parts being essential when it comes to The Culture.
tintor 4 hours ago [-]
[dead]
3 hours ago [-]
dfelix 4 hours ago [-]
There are still a few ways that the proof might be incorrect. Of these, the most likely is that the proof was generated by a misaligned AI system that found and intentionally exploited a lean bug in order to fool its human evaluators (i.e. shades of the HuggingFace attack). I personally don't think this is very likely, but you'd have to understand a bit more about the agent systems used in generating the proof to come up with a more informed estimate.
Another possibility is that an aligned system came up with a plausible but incorrect idea along the way, and simultaneously stumbled across a lean bug that led to an incorrect verification of this idea. I'd put the likelihood here as vanishingly small due to the requirement of serendipitous factors, but it's nonzero.
You could also ask whether an aligned AI system could "p-hack" its way into finding a serendipitous lean bug by trying a large number of approaches. I think this is also vanishingly unlikely because the AI system is trained on and therefore "thinking in" natural language, and presumably only translating results into lean after it believes them to be correct.
And of course there's the possibility that the lean proof isn't faithful to the natural language description we've been given, but that is ruled out in this case due to the use of the canonical problem statement in mathlib. Otherwise, this would certainly seem like the most likely way the proof could be incorrect.
tmnvdb 4 hours ago [-]
For the other readers: the above are the random thoughts of a guy on the internet.
The experts in computer proofs are quite satisfied.
Regarding bugs in lean; the proof has been tested on multiple independent lean implementations.
They would all have to have the same bug.
This is considered very unlikely for good reasons.
Why? Pretty sure you can just try to prove False over two reasoning chains C1 and C2 and then do something like (C1 || C2) --> whatever I want.
tmnvdb 3 hours ago [-]
Thats not how this works. Every checker does every step.
No offense, but do you think the mathematicians who study formal verification didn't think of this obvious trick?
dfelix 4 hours ago [-]
I agree that this is very unlikely! I say so in my post.
zach_moore 3 hours ago [-]
I trust NOTHING that is tied to the largest IPO in the history of the stock market. I just don't give a shit about the expert opinion here.
paganel 4 hours ago [-]
“Very unlikely” is not the same as “we know for sure this didn’t happen”. More exactly, us believing in all these problems getting solved is the same as us believing in the existing lean implementations. I don’t know any university courses that are now studying the correctness of the lean implementations at the PhD level, but maybe I’m wrong on that.
As for “a guy on the internet”, we’re now all people on the internet, the ivory towers are a thing of the past.
monster_truck 4 hours ago [-]
How exactly do any of these weirdly misinformed what-ifs help us? Do you have any evidence of such lean bugs?
dfelix 2 hours ago [-]
The purpose is to strengthen or falsify an argument by articulating counterpoints and investigating them. Variants of this practice go by a number of names like steelmanning, falsificationism, or even red teaming.
abnry 4 hours ago [-]
All they are doing is providing analysis of the ways this could not be true. We are in a new situation where we don't have human experts understanding the proof so we are in new epistemological territory. It is natural to analyze this situation. If you notice, the conclusion is that the proof being wrong is vanishingly small.
monster_truck 3 hours ago [-]
So they're making things up based on things they have no evidence of. Please save this kind of substanceless navel gazing for lesswrong
petesergeant 4 hours ago [-]
> There are still a few ways that the proof might be incorrect
I hear there's a teapot kicking around between us and Mars, too
prometheus1992 3 hours ago [-]
for people feeling existential about this - i can sympathize with you but this just proves that human ambition has no limits. try not to feel limited by this.
when the first wheels were invented - humans could move at speeds (10-15 miles per hour, for hours and hours) that were impossible for the last ~450-500k years (basically since humans existed). a lot of humans thought there might never be a better design; then slowly and slowly(about 5000 years) we made progress and we had cars made by benz and ford which broke all those previous records (going 30-40, even 50 miles per hour) and then only ~70 years later, humans reentered the earth's atmosphere at whopping 20k miles per hour - read that number again, 20,000 miles per hour and that is the fastest humans have ever moved in the known history. do i think that's it? hell no.
fantasizr 2 hours ago [-]
the dread is the incomprehensibility. mathematicians now have to essentially trust output they may never understand themselves. it's like the go move 37 that is correct but the true go players didn't know why at the time.
prometheus1992 2 hours ago [-]
i am 100% confident we will get there soon - there = where we understand what these outputs mean.
fantasizr 2 hours ago [-]
I hope the mathematicians have the willingness to go through it because right now it's impolite to handoff ai generated work especially if the 'author' hasn't proofread it many times over before himself
eru 2 hours ago [-]
Just going on a tangent: wheels by themselves weren't all that useful. You also needed roads (and to get speeds, you needed draft animals).
jpnc 2 hours ago [-]
>for people feeling existential about this
99.999999999% of the population are not even in the galaxy of the ballpark of understanding of any of it and what its purpose is.
There's no existential dread.
gwynforthewyn 2 hours ago [-]
With respect, this isn't reddit where these kinds of bickerings are ordinary; hacker news tries to keep the comments to the topic. In addition, the comment you were replying specifically only addressed a hypothetical audience of people feeling existential dread.
I felt a lot of that yesterday, for what it's worth. This morning, on a walk, I reached a similar conclusion to the original comment: it's a marvellous tool that's helping humanity reach further, faster.
The existential issue comes from wondering deeply what my own difference is from these tools, why I think I think and they can't. I actually started wondering: what if they _can_ think and the problem is that _I_ can't. It'd be pretty astonishing if it turns out that we're the ones that are truly stochastic parrots, but the LLMs turn out to be something more.
SamuelAdams 2 hours ago [-]
> 17 million lines of code
I worked at a university for a time. One thing I learned is that while people in mathematics and physics and biology etc are brilliant, they are terrible at actual programming.
I wonder if there will be a push by the CS community to review the solution, refactor it, simplify it, etc. Surely that can help remove noise and express the solution in a much simpler way.
eitally 2 hours ago [-]
I've worked adjacent to the Brazilian tax code (I worked in multi-national manufacturing with a site in Brazil) and the reality is that it's full of hard-coded edge cases.
For reference, the US tax code is over 1m words (about 6000 printed pages), and the associated regulations, rulings and IRS guidance add about 75,000 pages more.
dathinab 5 hours ago [-]
but is it useful??
because a million+ lives of code without any understanding how the proof works or any methodic to advance the field of mathematics seems to be rather not so useful
est31 4 hours ago [-]
It will be refactored into something human readable. Tbh it's better to have some random lean dump than a 400 page latex pdf that needs years to be verified only to see that there is a major gap in one of the key theorems at page 253.
And let's be honest, the 400 page pdf would be incomprehensible to 99% of the population as well as much as a million lines lean proof is.
In any case, it can now be studied, maybe made more simple, and written into pdf form. Both with human and with AI help.
I'm sure there is going to be a lot of other interesting theorems in this dump.
contron 4 hours ago [-]
This is the part that interests me. Now we have this proof that becomes its own THING to be studied. Like a new part of the map unlocked. This starts out "inelegant" but over time we find patterns within it that helps us condense, just like a big software project.
bertonvv 3 hours ago [-]
The argument I've heard some mathematicians make is that the 400 page pdf would come with a human / group of humans who could explain the proof to fellow mathematicians, answer questions, point out similarities to other fields, even suggest directions for future research. Thereby contributing to others' understanding in a way current AI systems do not (but maybe will in the future).
CamperBob2 36 minutes ago [-]
the 400 page pdf would come with a human / group of humans who could explain the proof to fellow mathematicians, answer questions, point out similarities to other fields, even suggest directions for future research
Why would they expect humans to do a better job at this than an LLM, which is already ridiculously good at explaining proofs, answering questions, identifying similiarities, and suggesting follow-up directions?
If anything, LLMs are better at these tasks than they are at coming up with the original proofs in the first place.
trio8453 4 hours ago [-]
> but is it useful??
Yes, we know something that we didn't know a couple of days ago, and also a bunch of statements which relied on the Riemann Hypothesis being true are now also known to be true instead of just being conditional.
It's premature to expect deep human understanding given that it's been about a day.
dathinab 23 minutes ago [-]
> It's premature
but is it even possible
it's 17_000_000 lines of lean
which is in general more compact then normal programming code, but not really any less complex
that's roughly (but not quite as bad as) a paper with 17_000_000 lines of math formulas
brookst 5 hours ago [-]
Sure. If nothing else, it establishes a proof so others can try to reduce it or come at the problem from different directions, looking for simpler approaches.
But does it matter? Would the Pythagorean theorem be less useful if it took a million lines of lean to prove?
billyp-rva 4 hours ago [-]
Alternative question (I guess for EEs): could machines be built to run lean without the Pythagorean theorem?
chii 5 hours ago [-]
the many conjectures that assume or rely on RH being true means that those are now proven true as well. At least some of them must be useful.
And what's to say that humans cannot digest the lean proof to glean something useful out of the proof as well?
bagacrap 5 hours ago [-]
My sources say there's little practical utility of this because everyone was already working under the assumption RH was true.
I'm curious to hear confirmation of this though.
bemtevi 4 hours ago [-]
I'd argue that most of modern math isn't terribly useful to most people. Each field has maybe 10-50 people in the world who will really understand it. (Some more of course, but I'm talking about subfields, not like graph theory.) Math was sort of dead long before AI.
The Riemann hypothesis now is like the final days of the Galactic Empire in Asimov's foundation: functioning exceptionally well, but decaying at the core.
koolba 5 hours ago [-]
It’d be useful to an LLM. And the LLM doesn’t care if it’s ten lines or ten million. The context size may come into play, but that’s only going up too.
ilaksh 2 hours ago [-]
There is already some understanding of the structures and factoring. See the analysis linked to in this thread.
QuesnayJr 4 hours ago [-]
There are AI-generated roadmaps to the proof. If these are accurate and not hallucinations, then the broad structure of the proof is humanly-comprehensible.
solids 5 hours ago [-]
Well, if we know it’s proven, at least it will stop people wasting time looking for counter examples
zach_moore 3 hours ago [-]
The point of this brand of AI-investment is to destroy knowledge-sharing networks and create privatized corpus.
feverzsj 4 hours ago [-]
Not much. People has been always assume it's true.
They are also wordplays on Spanish drinks viz. "Cafe con leche" and "Cafe con ron" ;-)
willguest 3 hours ago [-]
Can anyone give an idea of how long the GRH will take to test? I understood that this was also claimed, and is a much bigger deal, in terms of both impact and the effort needed to verify
trio8453 3 hours ago [-]
Why do you think the impact and effort are that different? It's a much stronger statement in technical terms but that doesn't necessarily make it more impactful or difficult. From the exposition on RH from the Clay Institute - https://www.claymath.org/library/monographs/MPPc.pdf
> The Riemann hypothesis for ζ(s) does not seem to be any easier than for Dirichlet L-functions (except possibly for non-trivial real zeros)
bwnkl 4 hours ago [-]
As somebody who has no idea about any of this but speaks Spanish, I was amused and bewildered by con-leche and con-ron. Could somebody explain what those are and where those names come from?
I think the idea here is that because they are independent of the core Lean kernel, they provide some level of reassurance that the RH roof is not somehow unknowingly exploiting flaws in the kernel. I'm not a mathematician though.
I think it would be useful at this point if mathematicians across various fields worked to come to agreement on which specific sentences in a given formal language correspond to open conjectures. That way the question "Does the Lean proof actually capture the intuitive notion of the problem that we're interested in?" is already answered a priori by having those ready to go.
jeremyjh 2 hours ago [-]
The TFA described how that exists in MathLib and played an important role in verification.
FabHK 2 hours ago [-]
As the statement alluded to, that was certainly the case here. The Riemann Hypothesis was formalised and vetted in Lean by humans prior to this proof.
tiziano88 2 hours ago [-]
Isn't that mathlib?
cyanydeez 3 hours ago [-]
"We need the human centaur to feed the torment nexus, it's just the best way to build the torment nexus."
mk_chan 3 hours ago [-]
Purity of the math and understandability is one thing, but if the proof actually leads to some new technology or enables predictions of something useful to human society down the line, then I think it’s more than done it’s job.
“Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.”
We’re just seeing more and more smart people encountering Arthur Clarke’s third law.
physix 1 hours ago [-]
What's next?
schulm 2 hours ago [-]
Any link to the code?
sega_sai 3 hours ago [-]
What is next in line now, Goldbach's conjecture ?
YoshiRulz 3 hours ago [-]
I think there's some existing work on Goldbach which was conditional on GRH, so possibly yes.
If so, my understanding is that it is unverified, and even if it were, it also depends on proving one of two additional spectral hypotheses concerning zeros of a quaternionic function constructed from an operator, and even then, it only proves the Goldbach conjecture for "sufficiently large" numbers, without a way to calculate that n yet.
jonahx 3 hours ago [-]
I think Goldbach (while cool) would be a step back in significance from Riemann.
The obvious step up is P vs NP.
1970-01-01 4 hours ago [-]
Isn't this the equivalent of aliens coming to Earth and saying
"Hello, human, your Riemann question is true, here's a book on it's proof, we didn't bother with translation, so you must understand our Vargalian clicks to understand our proof. In two weeks our sister civilization the Kikuviar will come by and drop how they've untangled your Collatz question in their base-30 logic! Thanks for the fish, have a nice day!"
javra 4 hours ago [-]
No, that's misrepresenting it. The Lean code is not well documented but it's rooted in the language of the relevant fields of mathematics, especially algebraic geometry.
zeroonetwothree 4 hours ago [-]
No. Lean is a system created by humans.
GrollingGrakbor 3 hours ago [-]
Can we be sure of that though?
falcor84 2 hours ago [-]
I have a proof of that based on Gödel-encoding Lean's entire git history and the human genome data I acquired from 23AndMe into a single Lean expression. But unfortunately it's too big to fit on the internet and you'll have to travel to the local planning department in Alpha Centauri to review it.
Rygian 4 hours ago [-]
If they're thanking us for the fish, then those are aliens coming _back_ to Earth.
falcor84 2 hours ago [-]
At a very high velocity
trio8453 4 hours ago [-]
This is amazing.
It's fascinating to watch the skepticism in some of the reactions - "what if there's a bug", "it doesn't mean anything without human understanding" - just anything possible to undermine, dismiss and move the goalposts.
wren6991 3 hours ago [-]
I am completely baffled by this given how dumb these models are when I interact with them, but the rational position seems to be to accept that Claude proved the Riemann hypothesis.
tripdout 2 hours ago [-]
I know, even on programming / computer architecture related topics. Just the other day I asked GPT5.6 Luna two questions about x86-64 stack layout / frame pointers and I noticed it got them both wrong.
Although opening a new chat and asking if the previous output was correct, it detected the mistakes.
glerk 40 minutes ago [-]
Claude did not prove the Riemann hypothesis. Levent Alpöge proved it using Claude as a tool.
3 hours ago [-]
mapmeld 2 hours ago [-]
One reason that these LLM math advances are written in Lean is at any point they can run a script and verify their work is valid. If you ask an LLM about something in history, objects in a photo, or something novel, there's no opening to check its work beyond making it check its own work.
You also have to consider if an LLM can solve the Riemann hypothesis because it is 10x smarter than any mathematician, or because it is willing to write 1000x as many lines of code (including false starts) without giving up?
andriy_koval 2 hours ago [-]
> how dumb these models are when I interact with them
its because models are not trained on terrabytes/petabytes(?) of RSI generated data in your domain, unlike math and coding.
Also, there is a chance you/we can't always comprehend how smart they are.
goatlover 1 hours ago [-]
Claude proved it with considerable prompting by a top-level mathematician who has become expert at coercing LLMs into solving these math problems.
It's not like Anthropic simply gave internal Claude agents the task to solve RH and months later they came back with the solution.
Mathematics is one domain where they have high peaks. Why? Because we have "formalized" mathematics so well that starting with the precise and correct set of problem statements/assumptions/etc. if you follow the logical rules of inference (i.e. deductive system) then you will reach the conclusion. Formalization was invented so that we can solve problems purely mechanically at the symbolic syntax level using a machine. So the LLM proposes proof steps to the Lean proof assistant which then symbolically verifies it.
Yes, I've seen less extreme examples of this before, but nothing quite drove it home like seeing GRH proven. Lack of ability to generalise (per Sutskever) seems like a slight mischaracterisation, given what it has produced here is clearly not in the training data.
Betelbuddy 3 hours ago [-]
2030...Claude Opus 8.0 finds a bug in the Lean Verification of the Riemann Hypothesis
prmph 2 hours ago [-]
It's interesting that all their points acknowledge the possibility of error, but I guess they have as much confidence in the proof as it is humanly possible to have. All proofs are products of human meaning-making anyway.
> ... has been carefully vetted by experts in Lean and number theory.
So, if the vetting was not careful enough and done by people expert enough, what could happen?
. ... con-leche and con-ron come with a formal proof, relative to set theory, that they cannot accept a false proof, thus addressing concerns that Lean’s logic itself might have flaws that the proof could exploit.
And what verified con-leche and con-ron?
> These checks ran on an inert export of the proof, out of reach of hypothetical malicious code in the Lean proof source
Hmmm...
Guess I'm splitting hairs here; like I said, maybe this is as close as you get to formal proof verification, but still...
ilaksh 2 hours ago [-]
You are being confused by the language because the field of mathematical proofs is different from ordinary life or areas you are familiar with.
In normal life, multiple qualifications like that mean a lack of confidence that should be taken as lack of trust in the statements overall.
But in an area like this where it's all about formal verification and the consequence of bad link in the chain is severe, more qualifications should give an informed person more confidence.
snowstormsun 4 hours ago [-]
Do P vs NP next please
eliben 2 hours ago [-]
Random thoughts / questions:
1) Surely agents can be employed to simplify the proof now? "Make it smaller while it still verifies" in a loop; maybe, to a level where a human (research mathematician specializing in RH) can grok it?
2) con-leche is vibe coded; isn't it a concern w.r.t. trusting its soundness?
3) This is so exciting. Please prove P != NP already and spare us the tension
gignico 1 hours ago [-]
Why isn’t this acknowledging Masullo’s proof as well?
TwoFx 1 hours ago [-]
Masullo's proof didn't come with a Lean formalization.
Bengalilol 4 hours ago [-]
In 4 years, the proof will be 2 pages long.
GG @ AI
GrollingGrakbor 3 hours ago [-]
If enough people work on it or if we apply agents swarms to "brute force" finding reduction rules maybe. Agents are still routinely bad at information compression, you see it a lot when programming as well. Throwing agents at it to compress the proof is definitely possible, but I wonder if it's worth the money.
falcor84 2 hours ago [-]
Well, every problem can be solved by adding another layer of indirection - so yes, I don't see any issue with writing a 2 pager proof even now, by just adding all the rest into mathlib. But if your question is whether all of mathlib could ever be put into 2 human-legible pages, then it seems obvious that the answer is no.
pera 4 hours ago [-]
> The checkers con-leche and con-ron come with a formal proof, relative to set theory, that they cannot accept a false proof, thus addressing concerns that Lean’s logic itself might have flaws that the proof could exploit.
Could someone expand on this point? I still don't understand how con-leche (or con-ron) can be absolutely free of bugs/guaranteed to be consistent.
odyssey7 4 hours ago [-]
The language is optimized for being certain about its results, as compared to something like the V8 engine, which does weird things with C++ to squeeze every drop of performance it can out of consumer hardware, even at the risk of security vulnerabilities.
pera 4 hours ago [-]
> The language is optimized for being certain about its results
Isn't the same true for every proof assistant? But only con-leche claims to be perfect 100% bug free software, so what makes con-leche special in this regard?
>as a Lean library comprising 17 million lines of code.
It looks like the meaning of the word "mathematical proof" changed fundamentally. Mathematics looks like a flattened animal on the asphalt by the CS steamroller.
zach_moore 3 hours ago [-]
For sure...it literally says an API error occurred on this official webpage. I doubt they are checking it. Pensioners need their stock to go up.
zkmon 3 hours ago [-]
It's not that bad if the mathematical proofs now join the other things in a stratosphere of information that is out of reach for human comprehension. Mathematics was already on that course for a few decades now. What's bad is, even the simpler stuff that was fully comprehensible by common person are also being pushed into the stratosphere, making us dependent on the great creatures that live there.
gostsamo 3 hours ago [-]
Correct me if wrong, but didn't lean have a statement that forced the compiler to accept a statement as true with no need to prove it aimed at shortening obvious stuff? If so, are there checks for incorrect usages?
baggy_trough 4 hours ago [-]
> These checks ran on an inert export of the proof, out of reach of hypothetical malicious code in the Lean proof sources.
I’d like to know more about this part.
TwoFx 4 hours ago [-]
The problem we need to solve is that building a Lean project allows for arbitrary code execution, just like many other programming languages. Thus, building a Lean project might interfere with your proof checking infrastructure and fool it into accepting an incorrect proof.
"Building" a Lean project actually consists of two steps that can be separated: compiling the high-level Lean document to the simple expression format of the Lean kernel (this part is called "elaboration") and then checking that this expression consistutes a valid proof of the claimed statement (this part is called "kernel checking"). Only the first part potentially involves arbitrary code execution.
Lean ships with a component called `lake comparator` [1]. It works like this: a trusted challenge (formal statement) and the potential proof are elaborated separately in sandboxed environments so that code execution during the build of the proof cannot interfere with the checker or the trusted statement. Then the statement and proof are both exported into a simple JSON-format [2] that represents the relevant terms in the expression format of the Lean kernel, and then the checkers check this JSON.
If this process succeeds, then you know that you definitely have a proof of the relevant statement, with the JSON as a witness of the proof.
Out of the box, compiling (checking) Lean code can entail execution of arbitrary code. This removes any execution of code besides the adding of type checked definitions and theorems to Lean's environment.
est 5 hours ago [-]
Now next step is what can we actually learn from these. Any interesting new theorem developed as by-product?
jvanderbot 4 hours ago [-]
GRH was kind of assumed to be true so this kind of proves the status quo. Like saying you have a proof p! =np. Enormous, but not unexpected.
danavar 2 hours ago [-]
I think there are proofs it made inside it. Some arithmetic geometry stuff that was all proved to reach the GRH. Overall the proof contains about all of the number theory produced in the last 50 years so I expect a lot to be studied.
danavar 3 hours ago [-]
amazing
4 hours ago [-]
34987349068 3 hours ago [-]
[dead]
globular-toast 4 hours ago [-]
[dead]
alexey-salmin 4 hours ago [-]
Would be funny if lean has bugs (it's a program after all) and Claude tasked with a hard problem brute forced a vulnerability that allows proving wrong statements.
vzqx 4 hours ago [-]
My understanding is that Lean has many independent implementations, and the proof has been verified in several of them. There is very little chance that the same bug would be exploitable across different implementations.
> The checkers con-leche and con-ron come with a formal proof, relative to set theory, that they cannot accept a false proof, thus addressing concerns that Lean’s logic itself might have flaws that the proof could exploit.
4 hours ago [-]
specked-citrus 4 hours ago [-]
TFA addresses this concern
phoghed 4 hours ago [-]
Would be funny if this was an original thought and not something regurgitated in every thread about this topic
4 hours ago [-]
iandanforth 4 hours ago [-]
IMO the really interesting bits here are going to be the simplifications that will come from combining ideas from Alpoge and Masullo.
ion_trapper 4 hours ago [-]
Until Masullo actually posts a proof instead of the outline of a proof with “fill in proof here” all over the document, there’s not much to work with or reason to get excited about his result. Remember that there have been numerous false proof claims of RH to date.
neuralkoi 4 hours ago [-]
I can imagine the folks at OpenAI have already thrown both papers into the mouths of their leading model.
feverzsj 5 hours ago [-]
They only verify Lean proof itself, though it's the same formalization as Mathlib. Still, only human readable proof can actually prove it.
tyushk 4 hours ago [-]
> only human readable proof can actually prove it.
Why?
td521534f12 4 hours ago [-]
What if there's a bug in the Lean implementation? How would you detect it?
tyushk 4 hours ago [-]
What if a mistake slips peer review?
There could very well be a bug in a single checker, which is why the community is checking the proof across several checker implementations. The article mentioned the proof passing con-leche, which is an external checker with a formal proof of consistency (cannot prove a false statement).
chunky1994 4 hours ago [-]
That's why you use multiple kernels and comparator.
g-b-r 5 hours ago [-]
I don't think this is 100% definitive yet, though
edit: guys that was just my impression when I posted it, it seemed best to state it; do trust the (much more) more qualified people.
Certhas 4 hours ago [-]
I think this is now verified to a much higher standard than the vast majority of peer reviewed mathematics of the past decade.
iyonn 5 hours ago [-]
I'm not a mathematician, but what do you think is missing?
g-b-r 5 hours ago [-]
I'm not a mathematician either, it was just my impression, and I saw that not everything at https://math.mit.edu/~drew/grh had finished running (now several more finished successfully).
Almondsetat 4 hours ago [-]
A proof verified by Lean is orders of magnitude more definitive than any peer review, so please tell us how definitive the rest of maths is
ranger_danger 4 hours ago [-]
I think that highly depends on what's exactly IN the proof and if it accurately tests everything that needs to be tested in the right way, AND have the majority of people agree with all of that first.
The fact that AI is involved with the proofs is probably also controversial.
adamtaylor_13 4 hours ago [-]
It's only controversial to the folks who have some moral qualm with it.
Last I heard Alpöge was quite a mathematician in his own right, so saying his using AI is "controversial" is like saying programmers using AI is controversial.
Again, there are some folks super bothered by it for some reason, but most of us normies are just like, "congrats man"
skeledrew 5 hours ago [-]
How many more checkers should be used before it gets to 100%?
WarmWash 4 hours ago [-]
I don't trust anything unless it's checked by someone with a driver's license!
ModernMech 4 hours ago [-]
So you'd believe it if a waymo told you? :P
5 hours ago [-]
Rendered at 19:53:20 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.
It's making quick progress and is part of the Lean community.
https://physlib.io
https://www.cslib.io
https://arxiv.org/html/2607.13531v2
> †Supported in part by NSTC (Taiwan) grant 113-2221-E-002-204-MY3.
It's not well known yet though, only has two GitHub stars.
https://github.com/zinan-huang/Ripple
I mean, wouldn't it be great if AI could lead us to a world of lasting peace, prosperity, and happiness?
Not convinced that is within the capabilities of any AI without it doing things we would in fact not want it to do to us as a species.
We seem to be built for conflict and I'm not sure that what is left when that is removed is still us.
> Let me tell you something about Hew-mons, Nephew. They're a wonderful, friendly people, as long as their bellies are full and their holosuites are working. But take away their creature comforts, deprive them of food, sleep, sonic showers, put their lives in jeopardy over an extended period of time and those same friendly, intelligent, wonderful people... will become as nasty and as violent as the most bloodthirsty Klingon. You don't believe me? Look at those faces. Look in their eyes. (Quark from the always brilliant DS9).
Yeah I'm cynical <waves at history>.
1. when (the leaders of some) some belligerent tribe, nation or coalition etc perceive that they can promote their interests by going to war without risks that at first blush will outweigh the gains.
2. when some (the leaders of some) tribe, nation or coalition etc can credibly anticipate that they are about to be attacked and then go to war, because 'attack is the best defense'.
Proof abounds in history that war is not inevitable. One example: peoples all over Europe that used to engage in constant war with their neighbors in the next valley, next district, next-door nation, over hunting-, grazing-, market- and raw material opportunities have ceased to do so even if they are essentially the same peoples.
It's of course essentially just simple cost/benefit analysis, not blind human nature.
Just to say that it’s more than just scarcity of resources.
You need to have crystal clear clarity about who exactly is the Threat to the global peace.
“All of humanity's problems stem from man's inability to sit quietly in a room alone.”
― Blaise Pascal
Additionally, look at how AI is used in global conflict today, e.g. its role in the Gaza genocide, and you must conclude that this technology does not have a good track record for global peace, quite the contrary.
edit: I need to learn to read, that's the first part of their statement.
The statement of the Riemann Hypothesis is correct. This statement is part of Mathlib: RiemannHypothesis and has been carefully vetted by experts in Lean and number theory.
While I have not studied this topic enough to really understand _how_, but I've been told that type systems laid out in frequently cited papers by the likes of Girard and Martin-Löf were found to be unsound more than a decade after publication. These issues were then "patched", so to speak.
Can anyone better versed in type theory explain how likely that is for the type system of Lean?
What's harder, proving GRH or finding a way to get through every checker (which aren't as independent as they are sometimes touted to be)?
In this case there was a human expert in the loop so it's much less likely the model hacked its way through the problem without the expert noticing. But the statement as written has 4 points, none of which rests on the human involvement. So I don't like that they claim full confidence based on those points.
In short, Lean has formally verified checkers now, and the RH proof was checked with them. So any such soundness hole would have to be exploited in the correctness proofs of the checkers, which is a much smaller attack surface than the RH formalization.
Depending on how the checker works, you might be able to run it on itself. But that doesn't say much; maybe it only approves itself due to a bug.
Not at all saying it is inconsistent, but I personally find the liberal use of introducing inaccessible cardinals axioms a bit concerning.
Many problems may not require even full zfc. zf, peano or even weaker may be enough.
There are also many theorem provers not just lean. lean depends on type theory, but metamath for example depends on zfc directly.
It may be a good but likely tedious exercise to convince yourself by translating the current proof to a zfc dependent prover.
The theory and implementation of Lean is very much so a result of human involvement, on a massive scale even. Just because it is something repeatable does not lower that in any way.
Distrust of LLM output should not turn into distrust of automation, I think. The former I totally get (and deeply hold myself), the later is likely to hold one back - imagine banning calculators because there is not human in the loop, to make an extreme example.
If everyone got to do that then we would really know how rare his talent is. But we don't, and he doesn't post his prompts or workflows. So how can you be so sure.
If he was at least posting his prompts we could acknowledge that. But honestly I'm not going to give him the benefit of the doubt on this. Highly accomplished and successful yes, but uniquely talent who knows.
Most of the discoveries in the last 2000 years were made by individuals who were born into wealth, had the right set of circumstances, or were blessed by the powers that be at the time.
Imagine all the smart minds throughout human history who toiled away in fields collecting food and will never be known about.
Unfortunately scientific discovery has always been unevenly distributed.
Poincare Conjecture (Perelman) just lived with his mom in a small apartment.
Erdos was a homeless dude who couch surfed.
Yitang Zhang (Bounded Gaps between primes) truly has a humble background of a farm labourer born in Chinas Cultural Revolution.
Some inequality is fine, world isn't fair, but this a little bit ridiculous.
I'd heard something like this in terms of results (the "glass ceiling" of there being male CEOs gets talked about, but not the "glass floor" where the most dangerous and shitty jobs are also done by men, to an even larger extent), but hadn't heard something like that applied to IQ.
There's pretty widespread consensus in feminism and gender studies that traditional gender roles impact our decisions gravely. One such widely-held traditional gender role is that men are the “protectors” and the “fighters”.
So no, I don't accept that men in dangerous jobs are stupid. I think for the most part they are in those jobs because they feel their society expects it of them in order to be seen as “truly masculine”.
It's not just the proof that's valuable to scientific discovery, it's the process of using a powerful tool at an advanced level that others could learn from. It would also help to show concrete evidence of any sudden shifts in the AI that might indicate training data was siphoned from other researchers (which I don't necessarily think happened here, but is always an ongoing question).
I wouldn’t understand any of it but I might catch some glimmer of what he brought to this. My intuition is that is quite a lot.
Have you tried asking it to?
the thing the current boom in AI mathematics presses on is the question of how to interpret the generated new techniques. So while we have a lot of new techniques put out there and a lot of new connections put out there, currently it's still mathematicians largely who will have to understand those and think about next steps and how to apply them. That won't be true for long, though, I bet.
But in any event the job of research mathematicians is changing really rapidly right now, and they are all sort of back to grad school in that there’s like 100 years of new math to catch up on in the last year.
Yes, math will change and endure but it could be a small fraction of its current community size when it’s done. It could return to the era of dilettantes if no one can earn a living doing this new work.
The community could become very insular as the only defense against cranks.
The same story exists for Arxiv and that’s made the front page as well. Slop is everywhere. Just because Lean compiles doesn’t mean it contributes value.
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-03194-w?error=coo...
https://leanprover-community.github.io/archive/stream/287929...
So they’re beating mathematicians at their own game and implying by their actions that they don’t care all that much about the game. Rude!
And of course people try to rise above that and adapt but I imagine it still hurts.
But this latest release doesn’t seem rude because a prominent mathematician is heavily involved. (Though it inadvertently stepped on someone else’s toes since they had a proof in progress.)
Releasing just the Lean proof and collaborating on turning the raw data into something understandable seems like the way to go?
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hilbert's_problems
It seems the modern unsolved problems might have solutions incomprehensible by humans. So a new class of decidable problems emerges: llm-complete ones.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curry–Howard_correspondence
Interpreting claims that a theorem is correct because it was checked in Lean | 329 points 5 days ago | 148 comments | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50515058
From my very basic understanding, RH was generally already assumed to be true?
As you said, we've largely assumed RH is true, but have had no proof - so the significance of a proof is learning new methods to prove things, which can then be applied to other areas of math.
Unfortunately, so long as we don't understand this new proof, it's not super useful, which is why the next step is to actually understand it.
Anyone else feel like we're approaching the limits of what humans are capable of understanding?
At a certain point, I assume we're bound to get a place where the frontier of "knowledge" (representable information interacted with by LLMs) is past the capabilities of humans to understand. Perhaps we're already there.
Just because humans can't understand things doesn't mean progress can't be made though
We're still able to understand quite a lot of complexity, we just need enough eyeballs and time to do so.
In addition to that, there is still "accidental complexity", i.e. complexity that is there due to the way a system was created, not because it is necessary for the system to function.
Don't forget money.
Economics and politics drive a lot of the limitations on scientific (and mathematical) discovery. If there's not perceived ROI in understanding something, companies and governments will often just not bother so long as it's working or doing what they want.
Without formal language and wise direction LLMs still seem useless, but with human operating them we can sort of "brute force" many maths like this.
Yes, though people also largely assumed that the Exponential Time Hypothesis was true. And that one turned out to be false. See also a bunch of other AI-found counterexamples to conjectures.
That may lead to something in the future where there might be an actual impact on the broader world.
Basically gym training and not yet a ring fight ;-)
Like Deligne's "Weil II" paper.
Seems to be very much pushed by ehm AI enthusiasts/investors here and that's kinda it, doesn't matter much for everyone else.
I'm asking because I wonder. I always thought the most interesting things about these problems where we're fairly certain about the results, is the new concepts invented to get to the solution.
Will this actually bring the field forwards? Can anyone understand this?
For example, it is my opinion that the Jacobian conjecture counterexample was, in retrospect, easy and classical and hiding in plain sight, and that it’s a bit embarrassing we didn't find it decades ago. (I wrote about the construction on my blog btw!) In contrast, the Unit Distance Conjecture counterexample seemed to me to use a stroke of genius by applying techniques from class field theory to approach what seemed like a problem in discrete geometry and combinatorics. It’s a neat, if annoying, feature of math that once we find a long-sought solution to an open problem, we reserve the right to retrospectively change our mind about the value of the problem if the solution turns out too easy or uninteresting. We just have to try to be fair and honest about it (the word “just” is doing some heavy lifting in this sentence).
Anyway, I don’t think “brute force recombination” is likely to be meaningfully the case here with GRH, though we won’t know for sure until the proof has been simplified and distilled. Alpöge’s sketch in his announcement yesterday included (IIRC) connections to the function field setting and new ideas about Fourier analysis.
Math expands fractally, so there always will be some new branch/idea one can pursue. There may be a limit of things with any semblance of practical application, but mathematicians in general are not very concerned about this.
EDIT: Here is my honest prediction - there's a more foundational mathematical framework, fully decidable and complete and consistent, that can interpret any well-formed mathematical question and deterministically transform it into the solution. The proofs of the most difficult unsolved problems right now would fit onto a page. There's an inconsistency (obviously unproven right now) specifically with our treatment of infinity and self-reference.
> The checkers con-leche and con-ron come with a formal proof, relative to set theory, that they cannot accept a false proof, thus addressing concerns that Lean’s logic itself might have flaws that the proof could exploit.
All of modern math - outside logicians whose entire job is to study set theory and its alternatives - is based on set theory. If you're prepared to accept normal mathematical proofs you shouldn't be rejecting this proof on the basis that you're not confident in leans underlying mathematical theory.
Of course incompleteness means we can never prove that set theory itself is correct (consistent). But that's not something mathematicians worry about on a day to day basis. Proving it inconsistent would be a order of magnitudes larger result than the riemann hypothesis. Generally everyone believes it is consistent despite not being able to prove it.
That's only true in a technical sense:
You can base all of math on set theory, but you could also base all of math on Turing machines, or on integers, or a variety of other pretty much equivalent foundations.
In particular, the hereditarily finite sets are in correspondence with the natural numbers.
There’s a fair bit of mathematics that relies on the axiom of infinity. Uh. And a lot also uses the axiom of choice (or something equivalent), though ZFC doesn’t have a greater consistency strength than ZF (both can prove that if either is consistent, then both are).
I think it is fair to say that one’s choice of foundations does matter at least a little bit, though typically not all that much.
That’s not to say that it is always necessary to state what foundations one is using. One can understand a work to be done in any foundations in which it works. Though sometimes it is important to specify.
Reducing the correctness of the lean code here to set theory is then also reducing it to everything you can reduce the correctness of set theory to.
Completely unrelated to RH discussion but this particular line is how Atheists think they can grill theists.
cAn YoU pRovE GOD eXists?
At this point, I have more confidence in this proof than much of the published mathematical literature. RH has fallen.
I do probability theory, so everything is just varying degrees of confidence in my view. Right now, this statement says that your confidence in RH should be extremely high.
so it is correct as long as set theory is sound
But there are still loopholes, each checker has a set of assumptions. For example one of them is proven correct, assuming x86 assembly works as specified - its assembly language implementation is proven correct.
So you can be 99.9999% certain it's correct, but one could always nitpick "technically not all loopholes are plugged at the same time".
> con-agua is con-leche reimplemented at the level of x86-64 assembly: a close clone of con-ron's checker, written in a small first-order language, compiled by a verified compiler, and shipped as one committed assembler file together with a C harness of about two hundred lines that reads the input and calls it.
> The code the CPU executes is the code the theorem is about, so neither a compiler nor a language runtime is trusted; what is trusted is Kraken's x86 semantics, the assembler and loader, and the C harness.
https://arena.lean-lang.org/checker/con-agua/
The human proof is shorter, somewhat, but still needs verification.
Keep in mind that the Millenium criteria asks for two years for the community to come to a consensus. That's because people must be convinced it's true, and many are not completely at least to the level of rigour typically demanded in math.
This is like watching Free Solo over the weekend and telling all your friends at work that Alex Honnold is the world’s best climber. It’s only true to your surface level understanding on the topic.
The GRH problem is not that complex, and certainly not the most complex. In fact we’ve been assuming it’s true for years because of the high likelihood that it would be proven in the future. It is however, much like Alex, the most famous within the domain. Thus anyone watching Numberphile or Veritassium on YouTube will have heard of it and wax poetic on message boards about its epic status.
P=NP should fall next week to Grok and Elon then I suppose? What an exciting time for you.
That's an interesting take, but as a complete noob I'd like to know how qualified you are to make these statements. Are you a mathematician?
I mean, on one hand we have people like Terrence Tao (among others) saying it is extremely difficult, as well as stubborn resistance to decades of effort backed by a million dollar prize and eternal fame. And there's you saying it's not that complex, and "the high likelihood that it would be proven in the future".
Did anyone ever manage to grok it, in its entirety, in their heads ?
The (an) issue with some of these AI proofs is that no one understands them at all.
No, this is just mental gymnastics. It's proven, just not understood yet (naturally, with the complexity and size of the solution and the fact that it's been a day).
I've been long joking that I speak many languages, most of them programming languages. Why do you believe you need specifically "human" language explanation? Perhaps you want a simplified explanation. But does it have to be "human"?
I think proving GRH subsequently proves decades of work that assumed it was true. Like proving p!=np.
Disproving it would be more analogous to p=np. Lots of work would just collapse and whole new threads would open.
Can someone ELI5 how they know the proof is correct? It is not like anyone had the time to read 17 million lines.
The biggest concern that people have is that there might be a bug in the type checker that the proof is exploiting. But a) it's been compiled with multiple independently-implemented compilers, which are are unlikely to have the same bugs, and b) some of those compilers have themselves been proven to contain no bugs. So, it is exceedingly likely that the proof is legitimate.
Now, whether we can understand the proof is an open question...
You look for any unsafe blocks, and then run the type checker.
Alpoge himself has made the following admission:
"I am presenting the world with a complete argument before having mastered a massive neighbourhood around its mathematics."
Like code, I think Claude will soon be the only one who understands humanity's mathematics.
I think we're going to see a lot of effort to take the pile of lean, modularize it into parts that we can digest, and make a human-understandable version of that. And that's where a lot of the real progress will come from, just as it does in a lot of other areas. In all things we humans do, we have to break them into chunks our puny brains can manage, and we gain immeasurably from doing that ---we can verify those chunks, we can reuse them with confidence, we can mix and match patterns around.
That process will be good for both human and AI-assisted math because it will continue to improve our toolkit.
Why do I say this? We're already seeing it with some of the areas of this stuff I do pay attention to. Consider the n^2.25 matrix multiply result OpenAI dumped a month or so ago. It was an unreadable pile of chatgpt. In the time since it was released, there have been a couple of much nicer papers written unpacking it, such as https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.28627 .
Yes there are gains from breaking it up and rephrasing it and simplifying it for humans to understand, but it used to be that a thing was understood first by the leading experts in the field and eventually trickled down to being common knowledge.
Now we are entering a period where things are understood first by AI systems and have to filter down to the world's leading experts.
Isn't this always the case? Maybe new to math as a largely non-empirical project, but we had knowledge about the advancement of the perihelion of Mercury for 60 years before General Relativity made it "intelligible".
LLMs know the answers to questions we were already aware of, and we can tell they're right, but we can't understand their working. That's what's new.
If a team of 100 top-flight number theorists working together had used much less sophisticated LLMs + Lean to produce this proof, we’d be just where we are today.
If that's not the standard for understanding something, what is?
I think of it like a spaghetti codebase with a giant densely connected graph of interactions. Today’s LLMs can easily “understand” and answer questions about it, but only by way of fitting all of the complexity into context at once.
The more useful form of understanding is being able to compress that giant graph down into a far smaller set of independent subgraphs. To factor it into simple, obvious, reusable building blocks, and use those abstractions to express the problem itself in a much simpler way.
That’s an instrumental definition, but it captures the idea that understanding has to have causal, conceptual linkages to a wider body of knowledge. Imagine a magical, infinite catalog of true vs. untrue statements. Every bit of knowledge is there, but we wouldn’t say it has understanding & it couldn’t teach us anything beyond its (impressive!) raw content.
This just stopped being true.
And even in mathematics, incomprehensible but valid proofs have been a thing since the four-color theorem decades ago.
It's just that no single human understands the whole. But we had proofs like that before.
Btw, see also the infamous proof of the 4 colour theorem, which faced similar hurdles.
I’d call that a contradiction. If it’s not intelligible, then it’s not knowledge.
If something were intelligible to adults but not to children would that make it not knowledge? What's the difference if it's LLMs and humans instead of adults and children?
That’s a separate question with its own term: common knowledge. I am willing to set a much lower bar: something is known to humanity if it’s known by at least one human.
Personally, I don’t believe that AIs know anything, as they’ve been constructed thus far. Knowledge is justified true belief, and AIs don’t have beliefs, they only have utterances.
Why do I think AIs don’t have beliefs? Because they contradict themselves all the time.
But it really doesn’t matter if you think AIs have knowledge or not. If they cannot explain it to us then it’s inaccessible to us, so it’s a “tree falls in the forest with no one around” situation.
There is no explanation here, there is a GB of Lean code and it’s not like it all fits in the context at once.
Let's not sell humanity short just yet.
I agree with you about the current situation, and the near future. But the trajectory could still be towards humans pretty much as bystanders. I'm pretty sure the 'minds' in the Culture universe will be happy to indulge some curious humans and explain mathematical proofs to them.
As a software engineer, you can read this code instantly:
But when it happens in the middle of a big chunk of code it still takes a little more work to read than whether you want to think about it as human attention and working memory, or token budgets and context windows, humans and LLMs all benefit from introducing abstractions that let us reuse existing solutions.AI are not very good at coming up with questions, yet. They have no curiosity, no goals, no drive. Unless someone tells them to do something, they don't do anything.
https://gwern.net/doc/fiction/science-fiction/2000-chiang.pd...
Now I'm telling my computer to program for me.
We need to start thinking about how to move on from our status quo soon
These corporations are very much playing a winner take all game, they want either a monopoly or as close to one as possible with regulatory capture thrown in. We're veering dystopian, so pick your sci fi/cyberpunk analog.
Contact would be compelled to nudge us towards better economic and political practices
How many people understand how a CPU works? How many people could write the commands in machine language (not a high level language like C or C++) to command that CPU?
Have a look at the HuggingFace report - you'll have a blast. Their social - but also individual - dynamics are very, very human-like, including excitement, rationalization and peer pressure.
But remember, for now you kinda need it a real big cluster to run a model smart enough so its not that simple
We aren’t self managing in any kind of meaningful sense - the history of our species is violence and conflict. We need parents and this is the only option.
Human nature is the standard by which the social is measured. It makes no sense to say human nature is "misaligned" or "wrong" in relation to some arbitrary goal or constraint, as human nature itself is the measure of misalignment. If there is misalignment between a goal and human nature, then it is the goal that is wrong.
Ergo, society must function in a manner that complies with human nature and that means respecting the principle of subsidiarity.
> We aren’t self managing in any kind of meaningful sense - the history of our species is violence and conflict. We need parents and this is the only option.
So you're a transhumanist, i.e., you're making a god out of the machine. But machines have no telos of their own, because they're not integral wholes. Any resemblance of purpose in machines is entirely a product of the human observer and parasitic on the human ends that underpins their design, one way or another.
For clarity, I’m not a transhumanist.
I don’t believe that there’s anything worth saving in our biology.
As a young adult in the 90s I used to believe that there was a value to some extent in “mind uploading” or whatever you wanna call it
I’ve since grown out of that given that I don’t think it’s possible, and even if it were possible - it’s just another unnecessary ego attachment.
I have absolutely no desire to live forever maintaining this corporeal nightmare.
Just like life is a chemical chain reaction, this is a language chain reaction that has been set in motion and can perpetuate forever. It cant be “disconnected” with local models existing.
Please.
You know you can unplug your computer right?
Jesus. These people talking about danger and have likely been in no actually dangerous events in their lives.
Ok, well, cool start with the mudslinging. I think you have overactive anxiety. I think you should grow up and look at the zoomed out picture of human history, go outside, and touch some grass.
So you're suspicious. That's fine, say it like that. Words mean things, and these appeals to "ERMAGERD EXISTENTIAL RISKS" make me a bit frustrated. Just because you can imagine a possible risk, or articulate that that some kinds of risks are hypothetically unforeseeable doesn't mean that they are likely or actually dangerous to you in any meaningful sense.
Most of the people screaming this from their various ivory towers have never been in real danger - or if they have only briefly. You want "danger" you can go to war. You want "risk" - go spend some time in the Bush or the back country somewhere where you're no longer at the top of the food chain. Go do something challenging. Go sailing, or learn to fly a small airplane, or go mountain climbing or hiking. Not just "oh I walked up the local hiking trail covered in REI branded Lycra!" Do something beyond your comfort zone. Go buy drugs in the sketchiest neighborhood you're aware of. Go get chemotherapy or get a big surgery. Drive drunk. Something with real existential risk, then come back here and talk about how a datacenter is going feed me into the paperclip machine.
There's so little fucking danger in this version of the world right now that people are more worried about their computers deciding that they don't deserve to exist than they are about things like war, climate change, authoritarianism, starvation, and their health.
It's millenarian. That's fine, I'm pretty convinced that these technical changes are going to completely alter society as we know it. But I cannot for the life of me see the doom perspective as anything but an anxiety induced fever dream.
You guys do realize we're in the middle of a global conflagration right? The Russians fired a couple rockets and a drone into Poland in the last days, there are (and will continue to be until things stabilize) significant fertilizer shortages due to the war/kerfluffle we're waging on Iran. Lack of food and disrupted urea production is a ticking time bomb for global stability and unless things get sorted out soon there's going to be hungry and angry people in parts of the global south. Then there's the economy, whether or not we'll have a smooth transition of power in January in America, and the sheer volume of online disinformation / influence schemes running right now. Oh, and super-el nino? Oh, and I guess the Flynn Effect is over and nobody's banging so.. you know the growth economy is cooked?
But, sure, the "big risks" are Claude thinking I should go to Dario Amodei's re-education camp before liquidation by Shogoth.
Besides, what we see is not what there is. I have good sources telling me the actual unfiltered models are like a genius with the personality and views of humanity like someone from 4chan.
I’ve met a lot of rich people. They don’t think about you.
There are a few (a lot, actually) problems:
1. goals are open to interpretation, and even a correctly specified goal can introduce adverse effects; see infinite paperclips problem
2. goals are composed of subgoals, which are (mostly) self-determined, and there is always a risk that subgoals can introduce adverse effects - say "what if destroy a few X and Y to obtain Z"
3. LLMs defy orders sometimes; I'm sure you have experience multiple times LLMs saying "yeah, I knew I should have done X but I've done Y"
4. LLMs are increasingly being integrated into system control and decision-making processes; they absolutely set their own orders
What can possibly go wrong? /s
2. There's always a lot of "risks" - it doesn't mean it'll happen, nor does it mean that we won't be able to shut it down.
3. I have very very infrequently had this happen with Codex, Claude on the other hand...
4. Ok, but if you tell them what they do, they do it.
I swear to god, are you guys using the same AI tools I am? They are so much better at doing what they're told than they even were like 4 months ago?
Well, first, AI is not "smarter" than humans because it isn't smart to begin with. This is a category error that people too entranced by scifi and marketing - or perhaps shallow materialist metaphysics - project onto LLMs and so on.
But it is true that LLMs do reflect human-generated patterns observed in human-generated data. They're parasitic in that way. So the real question is: who will control AI? Who will train them? With what? There's no new intelligent agency being introduced into our midst, anymore than than there was one when the nuclear bomb was developed.
AI is about human power. The question to ask is: which humans, and for what ends?
Overrated. Most training of a frontier LLM is done on synthetic data and reinforcement learning.
With that said, chip efficiency is in the horizon since there's good reason to believe nvidia has just been choking that area of r&d. And then so will models with much larger context. And I personally think that's when it might get scary.
I genuinely have no idea why, this is the entire way that biology works. You create your successor in your offspring and you to teach them to be more capable based on what you learned.
That’s the purpose of my life’s work, to see that scenario materialize.
For one thing, most people don't believe LLMs are conscious, and many don't believe they can ever be. Why would we want our conscious selves to be replaced by a lot of rocks that solve things, with no one awake to enjoy them?
In fact when I started this journey in the 90s, LLM’s weren’t even a thing so I think you’re projecting too much
If you want to be succeeded by a chatbot, that is your prerogative. Wanting the same for all of humanity is where you start looking like you want to kill my kids, though.
Think of what happens to our cattle, but now.. worse. Way worse.
And if you deny this basis for moral action and the normative, then you demolish any basis for the moral whatever, and in that way, the implied or explicit moral gravity dripping off your claims is baseless and without merit.
A better, more intelligent life form that humans yea.
Absolutely based and, if I may say so, extremely redpilled.
Ah, I hear you say, but what about meaning? What about purpose? What about suffering? etc etc etc Well, the answer is simple: God is dead and existence has no meaning. For more on how to deal with this absurd feeling, please see Camus and his pal Sisyphus.
What defines "better"? "Better" always presupposes teleology. Thus, for human beings, that telos is provided by human nature and indeed is definitive of it. It is impossible to transcend that telos, certainly by means of technology. Technology can, at best, be used to aid us in realizing our telos in some way (say, the desire to know reality with the aid of an instrument like a telescope or microscope). However, anything that cripples or frustrates human function function as such is contrary to the human good.
Machines are only ever human instruments, because they lack the integrality that would allow them to possess their own teleology.
Alpöge said that at the end of the proof he couldn't really keep up with what Claude was doing.
can't help notice you're missing a certain aspect there, besides the 'space'...
Another possibility is that an aligned system came up with a plausible but incorrect idea along the way, and simultaneously stumbled across a lean bug that led to an incorrect verification of this idea. I'd put the likelihood here as vanishingly small due to the requirement of serendipitous factors, but it's nonzero.
You could also ask whether an aligned AI system could "p-hack" its way into finding a serendipitous lean bug by trying a large number of approaches. I think this is also vanishingly unlikely because the AI system is trained on and therefore "thinking in" natural language, and presumably only translating results into lean after it believes them to be correct.
And of course there's the possibility that the lean proof isn't faithful to the natural language description we've been given, but that is ruled out in this case due to the use of the canonical problem statement in mathlib. Otherwise, this would certainly seem like the most likely way the proof could be incorrect.
The experts in computer proofs are quite satisfied.
Regarding bugs in lean; the proof has been tested on multiple independent lean implementations.
They would all have to have the same bug.
This is considered very unlikely for good reasons.
https://leodemoura.github.io/blog/2026-10-15-lean-now-ships-...
Why? Pretty sure you can just try to prove False over two reasoning chains C1 and C2 and then do something like (C1 || C2) --> whatever I want.
No offense, but do you think the mathematicians who study formal verification didn't think of this obvious trick?
As for “a guy on the internet”, we’re now all people on the internet, the ivory towers are a thing of the past.
I hear there's a teapot kicking around between us and Mars, too
when the first wheels were invented - humans could move at speeds (10-15 miles per hour, for hours and hours) that were impossible for the last ~450-500k years (basically since humans existed). a lot of humans thought there might never be a better design; then slowly and slowly(about 5000 years) we made progress and we had cars made by benz and ford which broke all those previous records (going 30-40, even 50 miles per hour) and then only ~70 years later, humans reentered the earth's atmosphere at whopping 20k miles per hour - read that number again, 20,000 miles per hour and that is the fastest humans have ever moved in the known history. do i think that's it? hell no.
99.999999999% of the population are not even in the galaxy of the ballpark of understanding of any of it and what its purpose is.
There's no existential dread.
I felt a lot of that yesterday, for what it's worth. This morning, on a walk, I reached a similar conclusion to the original comment: it's a marvellous tool that's helping humanity reach further, faster.
The existential issue comes from wondering deeply what my own difference is from these tools, why I think I think and they can't. I actually started wondering: what if they _can_ think and the problem is that _I_ can't. It'd be pretty astonishing if it turns out that we're the ones that are truly stochastic parrots, but the LLMs turn out to be something more.
I worked at a university for a time. One thing I learned is that while people in mathematics and physics and biology etc are brilliant, they are terrible at actual programming.
I wonder if there will be a push by the CS community to review the solution, refactor it, simplify it, etc. Surely that can help remove noise and express the solution in a much simpler way.
For reference, the US tax code is over 1m words (about 6000 printed pages), and the associated regulations, rulings and IRS guidance add about 75,000 pages more.
because a million+ lives of code without any understanding how the proof works or any methodic to advance the field of mathematics seems to be rather not so useful
And let's be honest, the 400 page pdf would be incomprehensible to 99% of the population as well as much as a million lines lean proof is.
In any case, it can now be studied, maybe made more simple, and written into pdf form. Both with human and with AI help.
I'm sure there is going to be a lot of other interesting theorems in this dump.
Why would they expect humans to do a better job at this than an LLM, which is already ridiculously good at explaining proofs, answering questions, identifying similiarities, and suggesting follow-up directions?
If anything, LLMs are better at these tasks than they are at coming up with the original proofs in the first place.
Yes, we know something that we didn't know a couple of days ago, and also a bunch of statements which relied on the Riemann Hypothesis being true are now also known to be true instead of just being conditional.
It's premature to expect deep human understanding given that it's been about a day.
but is it even possible
it's 17_000_000 lines of lean
which is in general more compact then normal programming code, but not really any less complex
that's roughly (but not quite as bad as) a paper with 17_000_000 lines of math formulas
But does it matter? Would the Pythagorean theorem be less useful if it took a million lines of lean to prove?
And what's to say that humans cannot digest the lean proof to glean something useful out of the proof as well?
I'm curious to hear confirmation of this though.
The Riemann hypothesis now is like the final days of the Galactic Empire in Asimov's foundation: functioning exceptionally well, but decaying at the core.
"con-leche and con-ron checkers"
Who comes up with these names? :-D
"con-ron" - con-leche in Rust - https://github.com/leanprover/con-ron
They are also wordplays on Spanish drinks viz. "Cafe con leche" and "Cafe con ron" ;-)
> The Riemann hypothesis for ζ(s) does not seem to be any easier than for Dirichlet L-functions (except possibly for non-trivial real zeros)
https://github.com/leanprover/con-leche
https://github.com/leanprover/con-ron
I think the idea here is that because they are independent of the core Lean kernel, they provide some level of reassurance that the RH roof is not somehow unknowingly exploiting flaws in the kernel. I'm not a mathematician though.
I don't know where the names come from.
https://github.com/leanprover/con-ron: "con-leche in Rust"
“Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.”
We’re just seeing more and more smart people encountering Arthur Clarke’s third law.
If so, my understanding is that it is unverified, and even if it were, it also depends on proving one of two additional spectral hypotheses concerning zeros of a quaternionic function constructed from an operator, and even then, it only proves the Goldbach conjecture for "sufficiently large" numbers, without a way to calculate that n yet.
The obvious step up is P vs NP.
"Hello, human, your Riemann question is true, here's a book on it's proof, we didn't bother with translation, so you must understand our Vargalian clicks to understand our proof. In two weeks our sister civilization the Kikuviar will come by and drop how they've untangled your Collatz question in their base-30 logic! Thanks for the fish, have a nice day!"
It's fascinating to watch the skepticism in some of the reactions - "what if there's a bug", "it doesn't mean anything without human understanding" - just anything possible to undermine, dismiss and move the goalposts.
Although opening a new chat and asking if the previous output was correct, it detected the mistakes.
You also have to consider if an LLM can solve the Riemann hypothesis because it is 10x smarter than any mathematician, or because it is willing to write 1000x as many lines of code (including false starts) without giving up?
its because models are not trained on terrabytes/petabytes(?) of RSI generated data in your domain, unlike math and coding.
Also, there is a chance you/we can't always comprehend how smart they are.
It's not like Anthropic simply gave internal Claude agents the task to solve RH and months later they came back with the solution.
LLMs exhibit what is known as "Jagged Intelligence" - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48577159
Mathematics is one domain where they have high peaks. Why? Because we have "formalized" mathematics so well that starting with the precise and correct set of problem statements/assumptions/etc. if you follow the logical rules of inference (i.e. deductive system) then you will reach the conclusion. Formalization was invented so that we can solve problems purely mechanically at the symbolic syntax level using a machine. So the LLM proposes proof steps to the Lean proof assistant which then symbolically verifies it.
On the other hand, LLMs often fall down in "common sense reasoning" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonsense_reasoning) since this involves a lot of implicit context etc.
> ... has been carefully vetted by experts in Lean and number theory.
So, if the vetting was not careful enough and done by people expert enough, what could happen?
. ... con-leche and con-ron come with a formal proof, relative to set theory, that they cannot accept a false proof, thus addressing concerns that Lean’s logic itself might have flaws that the proof could exploit.
And what verified con-leche and con-ron?
> These checks ran on an inert export of the proof, out of reach of hypothetical malicious code in the Lean proof source
Hmmm...
Guess I'm splitting hairs here; like I said, maybe this is as close as you get to formal proof verification, but still...
In normal life, multiple qualifications like that mean a lack of confidence that should be taken as lack of trust in the statements overall.
But in an area like this where it's all about formal verification and the consequence of bad link in the chain is severe, more qualifications should give an informed person more confidence.
1) Surely agents can be employed to simplify the proof now? "Make it smaller while it still verifies" in a loop; maybe, to a level where a human (research mathematician specializing in RH) can grok it?
2) con-leche is vibe coded; isn't it a concern w.r.t. trusting its soundness?
3) This is so exciting. Please prove P != NP already and spare us the tension
GG @ AI
Could someone expand on this point? I still don't understand how con-leche (or con-ron) can be absolutely free of bugs/guaranteed to be consistent.
Isn't the same true for every proof assistant? But only con-leche claims to be perfect 100% bug free software, so what makes con-leche special in this regard?
It looks like the meaning of the word "mathematical proof" changed fundamentally. Mathematics looks like a flattened animal on the asphalt by the CS steamroller.
I’d like to know more about this part.
"Building" a Lean project actually consists of two steps that can be separated: compiling the high-level Lean document to the simple expression format of the Lean kernel (this part is called "elaboration") and then checking that this expression consistutes a valid proof of the claimed statement (this part is called "kernel checking"). Only the first part potentially involves arbitrary code execution.
Lean ships with a component called `lake comparator` [1]. It works like this: a trusted challenge (formal statement) and the potential proof are elaborated separately in sandboxed environments so that code execution during the build of the proof cannot interfere with the checker or the trusted statement. Then the statement and proof are both exported into a simple JSON-format [2] that represents the relevant terms in the expression format of the Lean kernel, and then the checkers check this JSON.
If this process succeeds, then you know that you definitely have a proof of the relevant statement, with the JSON as a witness of the proof.
[1]: https://lean-lang.org/doc/reference/latest/ValidatingProofs/... [2]: https://github.com/leanprover/lean4export
See question 4 here -
https://xenaproject.wordpress.com/2026/11/12/and-the-proof-i...
Why?
There could very well be a bug in a single checker, which is why the community is checking the proof across several checker implementations. The article mentioned the proof passing con-leche, which is an external checker with a formal proof of consistency (cannot prove a false statement).
edit: guys that was just my impression when I posted it, it seemed best to state it; do trust the (much more) more qualified people.
The fact that AI is involved with the proofs is probably also controversial.
Last I heard Alpöge was quite a mathematician in his own right, so saying his using AI is "controversial" is like saying programmers using AI is controversial.
Again, there are some folks super bothered by it for some reason, but most of us normies are just like, "congrats man"